“The intent of this Request for Qualifications is to make the response process as straightforward as possible in order to encourage submittals from the most capable and best-qualified developers,” the City and Borough of Juneau stated in its formal solicitation, which opened Thursday.
The RFQ marks the city’s latest attempt to catalyze redevelopment on the 1.4-acre downtown site after delays, a pending lawsuit, and a market analysis that found the project cannot break even without significant public subsidy.
Developers have until 2 p.m. on Feb. 11 to submit qualifications. An optional pre-solicitation conference and site tour is scheduled for Dec. 17, with registration required by Dec. 16. The city is not requesting design proposals or financial analysis at this stage; those come later, after a shortlist is selected.
The numbers that make the project ‘stuck’
A 2024 market analysis commissioned by the city found no version of the project that would break even. For a building with 80% market-rate apartments, 20% affordable units, and no new parking, the study calculated a gap of roughly $68,000 to $137,000 per unit, depending on construction costs, even with a 12-year, 80% property tax abatement. The city’s housing fund has historically contributed about $50,000 per unit in past projects.
To close that gap, the RFQ outlines a suite of incentives: city-funded demolition and site work, the 12-year tax cut, grants or loans of up to $50,000 per unit from the affordable housing fund, and a land price that is “potentially negotiable or deferred.”
The RFQ explicitly acknowledges “feasibility challenges” from the site’s steep slopes, the high cost of construction and borrowing, and the limited buildable area — just 1.78 acres of the roughly four-acre parcel. The request for qualifications acknowledges feasibility challenges and states that projects requiring less city subsidy will score higher.
Historic homes built 1882 to 1939 on Telephone Hill
The seven houses on the hill were built between 1882 and 1939. Until March, the oldest served as Juneau’s longest continuously occupied residence, according to the Alaska Historical Association, which has applied to list the hill as a national historic district. The city’s Historic Resources Advisory Committee voted 6-0 in October to support that application, though listing alone would not halt demolition unless federal money is used.
Opposition has been consistent. “From what I know, the proposed development on Telephone Hill of 155 units with 25 affordable is not financially feasible,” Mayor Beth Weldon said at the Assembly’s May 18 meeting.
Residents have testified throughout the year urging the city to pause spending, return the land to private ownership, preserve the historic houses, or rethink the project before selecting a developer. A lawsuit challenging the legality of the project remains pending.
The state purchased the hill in 1971 for state offices and once envisioned a new Capitol there. It declared the land surplus in 2019 and transferred it to the city in 2022. Voters approved $2 million for redevelopment via the 1% sales tax that year.
In 2025, the Assembly earmarked $5.5 million, including that $2 million, for demolition and site work. In April, the Assembly directed staff to hold off on demolition bids until a developer provides site-specific plans.
What the developer must accept
Whoever is selected must agree to an “open book” process, allowing the city to review project finances to ensure “no inappropriate windfall profit arising from public property.” Housing fund money carries conditions: 20% of units — 31 of 155 — must be affordable to households earning 80% of area median income for at least 10 years or the life of the loan.
Units built with the fund or the tax break cannot be used as short-term rentals. To protect views of the mountains and water, the city recommends keeping buildings no taller than 65 feet. The site sits in a downtown zone where new housing does not require parking.
Teams can propose building on all or part of the site. The Assembly reviewed the scoring criteria at a Nov. 2 work session. After the RFQ closes Feb. 11, the city will review proposals, select a shortlist, and move toward finalizing an agreement — a process slated to happen between now and next fall.