Kameron Pratt Challenges Nevada Attorney General Dual Role

Facing six felony counts of sexual abuse of a prisoner, Nevada Department of Corrections employee Kameron Pratt now finds himself at the center of a striking legal paradox.

The Nevada Attorney General’s Office brought the criminal charges against Pratt while simultaneously representing him in a related civil complaint filed by the victim, according to records from nvcourts.gov. In that civil proceeding in district court, the state’s attorneys filed an answer formally denying all allegations of wrongdoing on Pratt’s part.

Pratt moved to dismiss the criminal complaint for lack of probable cause. Alternatively, his defense asked the court to recuse the Nevada Attorney General’s Office from prosecuting the criminal case, pointing to the obvious conflict of representing a defendant in one courtroom while trying to put him away in another. The district court denied that motion.

When Pratt then filed a mandamus petition seeking to reverse that denial, the district court turned it down without prejudice. That procedural hurdle brought the dispute to an oral argument scheduled for 1:30 p.m. before Panel B26 in Carson City, as detailed by nvcourts.gov.

Nevada attorney general aaron ford addresses the united nations human rights committee, october (cropped)

Pratt’s defense argues that the district court abused its discretion. The core contention rests on a fundamental contradiction: how an office of the state can vigorously prosecute a criminal defendant while formally maintaining in a civil court that he committed no offense whatsoever.

The district court denied the petition without prejudice, leaving the door open for further litigation on the matter. Whether the prosecution can maintain this dual role as both civil defender and criminal prosecutor remains to be settled by the panel.