Morales Team Vows to Implement Providence Divestment Ordinance Despite Legal Concerns

More than three-quarters of Providence voters backed Question 7 on Nov. 3, giving a citizen-led divestment measure roughly 76% support at the ballot box.

The transition team for Providence Mayor-elect David Morales is preparing to implement that ordinance and defend it in court if necessary, according to Rhode Island Current. Under this rule, the city is directed to limit or withdraw municipal funds connected to nations accountable for, or businesses involved in, major human rights abuses.

“Providence voters overwhelmingly supported Question 7, and the Morales administration intends to honor that vote,” June Rose, executive director of Morales’ mayoral transition, told Rhode Island Current in an email on Friday.

The ordinance does not single out Israel by name, but both organizers and opponents identify the country as its target. Supporters cite Israeli military actions in Gaza as genocide, while opponents dispute that characterization.

Providence Mayor-elect David Morales defends democratic socialist agenda, Israel divestment plan — NBC 10 WJAR

The incoming administration’s stance follows a retired federal judge’s advisory opinion requested by the outgoing Brett Smiley administration. That opinion concluded the measure could lead to numerous legal headaches for the city.

Organizers collected a little over 6,000 verified signatures to place the measure on the ballot through a citizen-led process outlined in the city charter.

Morales Team Vows to Implement Providence Divestment Ordinance Despite Legal Concerns
Photo: yahoo.com

During the transition, Rose said the team is having conversations with the ordinance’s authors and investment professionals. Once Morales takes office in January, his personnel will work alongside the city treasurer, the legal division of the city, and the Board of Investment Commissioners to conduct an assessment of the municipal portfolio.

The city treasurer’s first report on municipal investments is due by the end of January 2027.

Dave Talan, Morales’ Republican opponent in the mayoral election and a board member of the Rhode Island Coalition for Israel, told Rhode Island Current that he is certain the measure will face legal scrutiny in court. Talan questioned how the measure would work mechanically, arguing that mutual funds make complete divestment nearly impossible since major companies operate in Israel.

Providence Mayor-elect David Morales — NBC 10 WJAR

Brian Sullivan, spokesperson for the Jewish Alliance of Greater Rhode Island, pointed to a Nov. 4 statement from president and CEO Steven A. Baker. Baker wrote that while the Alliance believes Question 7 was a divisive measure with adverse consequences for the city’s finances and community, its focus remains on bringing people together and confronting antisemitism.

Retired federal judge William E. Smith criticized the measure in his advisory opinion, writing that it lacks the precision to effectively define core human rights violations. Smith argued that even a narrow reading would require the city’s Investment Commission to make contested judgments about findings concerning China, Myanmar, and Israel.

Morales team vows to implement divestment ordinance despite
Photo: khanlist.com

Andrew Spacone, a Roger Williams University law professor, agreed with much of Smith’s assessment. Spacone told Rhode Island Current that unloading investments can trigger financial losses and that potential litigation could deplete pension assets.

“If the ordinance is challenged, the city will be prepared to defend it, just as it would any other city ordinance,” Rose said.

Zack Kligler, an organizer with the Providence for Palestine coalition, called the vote a resounding mandate. “Divestment will be an ongoing process over the coming years, and we will work to continue informing the public about next steps and the roadmap moving forward,” Kligler said in an email reported by Yahoo News.