Kentucky Supreme Court: Liability Insurer Bears Loss for Premature Subrogation Payment

Nine thousand dollars sat at the center of a Kentucky Supreme Court ruling that reorders who pays when insurance carriers trip over each other.

The court decided October 22 that a liability insurer — not the no-fault carrier that cashed a premature check — must absorb the loss when subrogation jumps ahead of an injured person’s right to be made whole.

The case, Allstate Property & Casualty Insurance Co. v. Jarnigan, traces back to a 2017 crash in Ohio County. Allstate paid $10,000 in basic reparation benefits — Kentucky’s no-fault personal injury protection — to its policyholder, Jarnigan. Before Jarnigan’s bodily-injury claim against the at-fault driver was resolved, State Farm, the driver’s liability carrier, paid Allstate $9,000 of that subrogation demand.

State Farm then told Jarnigan only $41,000 of the $50,000 policy limit remained. He settled for that $41,000. No one disputed he had not been made whole. MWL Law reported the court’s reasoning: Kentucky statutes KRS 304.39-070 and 304.39-140(3) place the injured party first in line, yet the majority held Allstate could keep the $9,000 paid by State Farm.

Writing for the majority, the court said the duty to protect the injured motorist’s priority belongs to the liability carrier that “volunteers payment to the subrogated carrier before the resolution of the claim of the injured party.”

If it does so, it “cannot assert any right to reduce the available coverage for that injury by the amount of the payment, and it must absorb the loss caused by its folly.” Insurance Business Magazine noted the decision reinstates the trial court’s dismissal on every count — no duty to repay, no unjust enrichment, no bad faith.

Kentucky Supreme Court: Liability Insurer Bears Loss for Premature Subrogation Payment
Photo: insurancebusinessmag.com

The court reasoned that a premature payment “will not be deemed to reduce the liability limits available to an injured person,” and the liability carrier “must absorb the loss caused by its folly.”

The ruling was not unanimous. One justice argued Allstate had a responsibility to honor the injured party’s priority once it knew retaining the payment interfered with that priority. Another would have allowed recovery under unjust enrichment. Insurance Business Magazine highlighted the practical gap: Jarnigan received $51,000 total — $41,000 from State Farm plus the $10,000 in PIP benefits — instead of the $60,000 he was legally owed, while Allstate’s net exposure dropped to just $1,000.

Kentucky’s answer is now binding precedent there. But the split decision shows why the outcome should not be taken for granted elsewhere. If your state lacks binding authority on this point, do not assume it will land the same way. The disagreement among the justices illustrates exactly why.

For claims teams working Kentucky auto files, the message is plain: track every open bodily-injury claim before paying subrogation, because the cost of jumping the queue stays with the carrier that wrote the check.