We expected at least one tracker to end up in a landfill. None of the 12 did.
KIRO 7 News Seattle dropped Apple AirTags into cardboard, aluminum cans, steel cans and heavy-grade plastic across King, Pierce and Snohomish counties to test the viral claim that curbside recycling is a scam. All 12 items were routed to facilities that process the specific types of recyclables put into the bins, and no tracker pinged from a disposal site.
“After you put the right stuff in the right bin, it goes for a hell of a ride,” Grace Fletcher of Waste Management told KIRO 7 News Seattle during a tour of the Cascade Recycling Center in Woodinville. “It goes to the right place and it gets recycled. So, I guess that’s the main takeaway here.”
The experiment disproves the curbside conspiracy, but public records obtained by the station reveal a messier reality once the trucks unload. King County’s 2022 material recovery facility assessment estimated 283,000 tons entered MRFs that year.
About 40,800 tons — roughly 14% — left as residue bound for disposal, and the county calculated that 40.3% of that residue was still recyclable material. That works out to roughly 16,400 tons of cardboard, PET bottles, aluminum, tin and HDPE lost after sorting.

Waste Management and Republic Services told KIRO 7 the losses stem from contamination and mechanical limits, not deliberate dumping. August 2026 data provided to King County shows the Woodinville plant processed about 4,922 tons with 714 tons — 14.5% — classified as residue, a rate nearly identical to the 2022 study.
| Material | Tons Lost in Residue (2022 Estimate) |
|---|---|
| Corrugated cardboard & kraft paper | 3,368 |
| PET No. 1 bottles | 861 |
| Aluminum cans | 671 |
| Tin food cans | 433 |
| Natural HDPE bottles | 133 |
| Colored HDPE bottles | 127 |
Those numbers track only what fails inside the plant. King County’s 2022 waste characterization study found a far larger leak at the curb: an estimated 172,600 tons of recyclable material went straight into the garbage — about 20% of everything disposed. That included nearly 36,800 tons of cardboard, 6,680 tons of PET bottles, 3,346 tons of aluminum cans and 2,899 tons of tin cans.
The stakes are visible at Cedar Hills Regional Landfill near Maple Valley, the county’s only active dump, which officials estimate will reach capacity in roughly 12 years. KIRO 7 compared the weight of potentially divertible material entering the landfill to the mass of 60 Space Needles.
Waste Management and Republic Services both warned KIRO 7 after the experiment that AirTags should never go in recycling bins because their batteries pose a fire risk during processing. The station does not recommend replicating the test.
Glass was excluded because Pierce County’s curbside program largely does not accept it; KIRO 7 focused on materials accepted across all three counties to keep the comparison clean.
King County, the most populous in Washington with 2,269,675 residents in the 2020 census, anchors the Seattle metropolitan area alongside Snohomish and Pierce counties. Originally named in 1852 for Vice President William R. King, the county council voted in 1986 to redesignate its namesake in honor of Martin Luther King Jr., a change the state ratified in 2005.
So the trackers prove the trucks go to the right place. The county’s own data proves thousands of tons still vanish — some in the sorting, far more in the trash can. The landfill clock is ticking.