WV, PA AGs Sue NJ, DC, PA Over Solar Credit Barriers

“The geographic restrictions serve no legitimate environmental or governmental purpose,” West Virginia Attorney General JB McCuskey said in a news release announcing the suits.

McCuskey filed lawsuits this week in New Jersey and the District of Columbia challenging state laws that bar electric suppliers from buying solar renewable energy credits from generators outside their borders, WCHS reported. Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday has filed a similar challenge, and all three cases target rules inside the 13-state PJM Interconnection territory, where electricity routinely crosses state lines but solar credits do not.

The practical stakes are immediate: West Virginia solar generators lost the opportunity to earn more than $25 million in credit revenue in 2025 alone, and the state projects Acts 40 and 114 will deny them more than $895 million over the next decade, according to the complaint filed against Pennsylvania.

Meanwhile, Pennsylvania ratepayers watched Tier I credit prices climb from $7.87 in 2020 to $29.29 in 2025, while Tier II credits jumped from $1.92 to $26.92, the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission reports.

WV, PA AGs Sue NJ, DC, PA Over Solar Credit Barriers
Photo: aei.org

“Whatever the purported environmental benefits of the 18 percent Pennsylvania market share for unconventional electricity, those effects are independent of the sources of the credits,” the American Enterprise Institute said in a commentary on the Pennsylvania case. The think tank argued the 2017 and 2020 laws were designed explicitly to “close the borders” and “protect Pennsylvania-based solar,” shrinking the out-of-state solar credit share from over 60 percent in 2017 to 1 percent in 2025.

“Acts 40 and 114 cannot yield environmental improvement—they can only shift credit purchases from out-of-state sellers to in-state ones,” AEI wrote.

The lawsuits lean on the Dormant Commerce Clause, which prevents states from enacting protectionist barriers that impede interstate commerce. McCuskey’s office argues the restrictions raise compliance costs for ratepayers in New Jersey, Pennsylvania and D.C. while shutting West Virginia producers out of markets they could otherwise serve through the shared PJM grid.

New Jersey and D.C. maintain similar in-state sourcing requirements for solar credits. The filings ask the courts to toss those geographic limits, arguing that electricity generated in one PJM state serves customers in another, so singling out solar for protectionist treatment is arbitrary.

Pennsylvania’s legislative history supports that view. When Act 40 passed in 2017 and Act 114 followed in 2020, sponsors were explicit: the goal was to limit supply and prop up in-state solar developers. The PUC data shows total Tier I compliance costs rising from $112.7 million in 2021 to $311.6 million in 2025, and Tier II costs from $78.4 million to $367.6 million over the same span.

PJM Interconnection, the regional transmission organization that operates the shared grid across the 13 states and the District of Columbia named in the suits, began in 1927 as the Pennsylvania-New Jersey Interconnection and was renamed the Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland Interconnection in 1956.

It became the nation’s first fully functioning independent system operator in 1997 and was designated a regional transmission organization by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission in 2001. Today it serves 67 million customers, coordinates 182 gigawatts of generating capacity, and runs the largest competitive wholesale electricity market in the United States.

Credit Type 2020 Price 2025 Price Out-of-State Share 2017/2020 Out-of-State Share 2025
Tier I (Solar) $7.87 $29.29 60%+ 1%
Tier II $1.92 $26.92 40% 0%

The cases now move through federal courts in New Jersey and the District of Columbia. A ruling striking down the geographic limits would reopen the PJM credit market to West Virginia generators and could force a recalculation of compliance costs for utilities across the region.