Ky. AG, UofL Foundation Seek to Rewrite Dead Donors’ Wills; Judges Split on Race Restrictions

Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman and the University of Louisville Foundation asked judges to rewrite the wills of dead donors, then watched a circuit judge hand them a stinging rebuke for ignoring the very law they cited.

Inside Higher Ed reported Friday that the contrast between the two courtrooms has sharpened the debate over whether public institutions are complying with the state’s new DEI ban or racing past it.

The foundation and Coleman’s office have petitioned to strip race and gender restrictions from at least five scholarships established by donors who can no longer object. They argue House Bill 4, which took effect last year, and the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2023 decision ending affirmative action in admissions make those restrictions illegal.

A Jefferson County judge agreed to open four scholarships designated for women to all students. But Judge Eric J. Haner refused to lift the racial restriction on the Newmark scholarship, writing in two brief orders that the foundation never even addressed the statute’s exemption for pre-existing endowments.

“The Court is uncertain if the Foundation and the Attorney General’s office just simply failed to read the law, or whether they engaged in willful obfuscation.”

Haner wrote, adding that the foundation could spend down the corpus as the statute allows rather than rewrite the donor’s intent.

Ky. AG, UofL Foundation Seek to Rewrite Dead Donors' Wills; Judges Split on Race Restrictions
Photo: associattedpress.com

Lucile Newmark died in 1952, two years before Brown v. Board of Education. Her will directed money to “colored students who may be entered in the Medical School.” The foundation and AG asked the court to remove that language, arguing the exemption in HB 4 applies only to endowments that will eventually exhaust their principal — not to permanent funds like Newmark’s designed to last in perpetuity.

Attorneys for the Louisville Urban League and the Falls City Medical Society, a group of Black physicians, counter that the statute sets no deadline for exhaustion.

“Wind down in 100 years? That’s still a date. Wind down in 500 years? That’s still a date,” Sadiqa Reynolds, a former U of L trustee representing the groups, told Inside Higher Ed. They also argue the fund could be transferred to a private entity that would administer it for Black students.

The university has tried to distance itself from the foundation’s litigation, noting its president and five trustees sit on the foundation board but insisting the Office of University Counsel does not control the foundation’s filings.

In a campus email Monday, the university said HB 4 “standing alone, would actually allow most existing race-based and gender-based scholarships to remain in place,” then pivoted to federal pressure: the Education Department’s Office for Civil Rights confirmed in July 2025 it is investigating a complaint alleging discrimination in six scholarships, though Newmark was not among them.

Coleman’s office says similar restriction-removal requests are moving across the state. A court filing footnote notes “multiple public postsecondary education institutions have requested the Attorney General’s consent to make similar amendments,” and that Bellarmine University, a private school, also sought approval for a modification.

Bellarmine told Inside Higher Ed it acted because its donors had died and only a court could change the terms under state law. Conservative activists have simultaneously targeted private scholarship providers such as the Hispanic Scholarship Fund, alleging their race- and sex-based criteria are illegal.

The Newmark case is now before the Kentucky Court of Appeals. Reynolds and co-counsel Ramon McGee filed a friend-of-the-court brief urging the university and foundation to “get off their knees and fight for Black students.” The next filing deadline is set for early December.

The outcome will test whether Kentucky’s DEI ban forces permanent charitable trusts to spend themselves into extinction or whether the legislature’s own exemption preserves donor intent until the money runs out — whenever that may be.