Lanai Resort Expansion Would Uproot Last Koele Ranch Buildings

September brought a 6‑0 vote by the Hawaii Land Use Commission to reclassify roughly 170 acres on Lanai from agricultural and rural to urban, clearing the way for a resort expansion that would uproot the last two buildings of the Koele ranching community.

Pulama Lanai, the land company owned by billionaire Larry Ellison, wants to add up to nine villas and five spa buildings on the 11.5 acres where the Forbes House and the Ranch Office and Store now sit, SFGATE reported.

The commission’s approval came with a condition: the structures must be relocated and preserved within the 170‑acre petition area, in consultation with the State Historic Preservation Division and the community, with “consideration” given to turning them into a museum or interpretive space.

“Once those buildings are removed and taken out of the area, that whole history of Lanai can never be recovered.”

Hermina Morita, who grew up in Koele and whose family lived in both houses, told SFGATE. Morita helped document the island’s ranching history and watched the Koele schoolhouse — relocated with promises of preservation — fall into neglect and meet the wrecking ball around 2018.

Koele lodge lanai hawaii usa

The dispute reaches the Maui County Council on November 25, when two zoning bills get their first reading after a Housing and Land Use Committee recommendation in October. Final approval would require a second reading.

At the October 21 committee hearing, Pulama Lanai senior vice president Keiki‑Pua Dancil pledged to preserve the buildings and create an interpretive space, but described moving them outside of the state petition area — a direct conflict with the Land Use Commission’s condition.

Land Use Commission Executive Officer Daniel E. Orodenker confirmed to SFGATE that the structures must stay inside the 170‑acre boundary. Pulama Lanai declined to comment for the story.

Koele once held more than 30 buildings — stables, a store, a school, a church, a post office and workers’ homes — serving the paniolo families who remained after the ranch closed in 1951.

Most were demolished for the Lodge at Koele, which opened in 1990 under Dole billionaire David Murdock’s Castle & Cooke. The lodge became Sensei Lanai, a Four Seasons Resort, in 2019, seven years after Ellison bought 98 percent of the island. Today the resort does not allow children.

Oct. 21 Maui County Council committee hearing

“It just keeps getting worse and worse,” Martha Evans, a longtime educator who lived in Koele, told SFGATE. “… As usual, the company just steamrolls everything.”

Martha Evans, a longtime educator who lived in Koele and later in the Forbes House, told SFGATE. Evans recalled a rancher’s wife threatening to tie herself to the house when the original resort development loomed.

“Their main motivation is to put their stamp on that piece of land, their stamp on the aina, and it’s not right,” Evans said, invoking the Hawaiian proverb: “He alii ka aina, he kauwa ke kanaka. The land is alii [chief]; the people are its servant. I truly believe that.”

Both women say more residents would speak out if they didn’t fear losing jobs with Pulama Lanai, the island’s largest employer. “You’re not going to testify if you work for Pulama Lanai,” Morita said. Evans, who lives on Oahu but keeps a home on Lanai, put it plainly: “My point is it shouldn’t move at all. They have enough for their resort.”

Pulama Lanai was founded in 2012 after Larry Ellison purchased 98 percent of the island, becoming the entity that manages its land, water, conservation and community services. The privately held company, headquartered in Honolulu with 201 to 500 employees, lists historic preservation among its specialties alongside development, agriculture and the operation of the island’s grocery store and utilities.

The commission’s condition does not require a museum, only “consideration” of one, and Pulama Lanai has not publicly identified a relocation site. For Evans, another move would sever more than wood and nail. “It erases a whole era,” she said.