US Home-Flipping Margins Hit 2008 Low as Texas Markets Collapse

“I don’t recall ever being negative on a sale,” Javier Maldonado said, “but I’ve broken even on some properties.”

In the second quarter, the median profit margin on a home or condo flip in San Antonio fell to a loss of 0.3%, property data firm ATTOM reported, making it the least-profitable major metro for house flipping in the country.

Nationwide, median profitability of a single-family home or condo flip dropped to 21.6% in the second quarter, the lowest level since the 2007-2008 housing crash, The Wall Street Journal reported. The decline reflects a cocktail of rising mortgage rates, skyrocketing property taxes, and an oversupply of inventory born from a residential construction boom during the pandemic.

Maldonado, who has flipped about 30 homes in San Antonio over seven years, told the Journal the math has gotten much tougher in the past year. San Antonio became the country’s least-profitable major metro for home flipping, with a median profit margin loss of 0.3% in the second quarter, while Dallas also saw steep slumps in profitability.

US Home-Flipping Margins Hit 2008 Low as Texas Markets Collapse
Photo: flipboard.com

The combination of rising mortgage rates, skyrocketing property taxes and oversupply from a residential-construction boom during Covid has made it the country’s least-profitable major metro for home flipping, the Journal noted, citing the ATTOM data.

While Texas investors absorb losses, the pain is not universal. Pittsburgh, Buffalo, New Orleans, Virginia Beach, and Philadelphia posted the highest profit margins among major metros in the second quarter, ATTOM data showed. These markets largely avoided the frenzied overbuilding that characterized the Sun Belt expansion.

The divergence shows a broader split in the housing recovery. Markets that added supply aggressively during the low-rate window now face a glut of new homes competing with investor-owned inventory, while older, slower-growth metros in the Northeast and Rust Belt retain tighter inventory and steadier demand.

For flippers like Maldonado, the strategy has shifted from rapid turnover to careful calibration. “I’ve got a formula that he said has helped him consistently make a profit—or at least not lose money,” the Journal wrote of his approach.

San Antonio anchors the Texas Triangle megaregion along the I-35 corridor, roughly 80 miles from Austin, and its metropolitan area of 2.76 million ranks 24th nationally. The city added housing aggressively during the low-rate window, a building boom that now leaves it with a glut of new homes competing with investor inventory — the very oversupply ATTOM cites as a driver of the median flip loss.

The national margin of 21.6% remains positive on paper, but it masks wide dispersion. In San Antonio, the median flip lost money. In Pittsburgh, the spread was wide enough to absorb rate shocks and still deliver a return. The gap between those outcomes is the new geography of housing risk.