Missouri Attorney General Catherine Hanaway is being sued by the Council on American-Islamic Relations on behalf of Mizzou Students for Justice in Palestine, challenging a civil investigative demand the group calls retaliation for its political speech.
The lawsuit, filed Friday in the Western District of Missouri, argues the demand — issued under the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act — violates the students’ First Amendment rights to free speech and association. CAIR attorney John Fossum said the statute, designed to police consumer fraud, does not apply to a university student organization.
“We are open to continuing to talk to the Attorney General’s office so that they can avoid the embarrassment of going to court,” Fossum said. “But as it stands, we are hoping for a temporary restraining order, granted ex parte, giving students relief not to have to provide this information.”
Timing raises retaliation questions
Hanaway’s office served the demand in September, mere minutes after a federal judicial panel allowed MSJP’s separate lawsuit against University of Missouri President Mun Choi to proceed. That earlier suit, filed in August 2025, alleged the university violated the group’s First Amendment rights by denying its applications to march in the 2024 and 2025 homecoming parades.

The investigative demand seeks member names, donor information, and financial records dating back to 2021. Fossum called the request broad and lacking any “legitimate connection” to a merchandising violation. MSJP President Sahar Bhutto, whose executive board ranges from 19 to 21 years old, said the group was shocked.
“Admittedly, I’m a little nervous because, I mean, we are a student group, it’s kind of a crazy thing to have the attorney general coming after us, especially for something so stupid and literally unfounded,” Bhutto said.
First Amendment clinic joins the fight
The Washington University School of Law First Amendment Clinic is co-counsel with CAIR’s Legal Defense Fund. “Public officials cannot weaponize their authority to suppress speech they disfavor,” said Arianna Khan, staff attorney at CAIR Legal Defense Fund. “AG Hanaway is violating the First Amendment, and we look forward to representing MSJP in federal court.”
The complaint notes Hanaway has publicly described Students for Justice in Palestine chapters as “propaganda” groups. CAIR argues the investigation was designed to dissuade MSJP from speaking out and to deter supporters from associating with the organization.
AG’s office silent on specifics
A spokesperson for Hanaway’s office acknowledged issuing the demand but did not respond to detailed questions by Friday afternoon. The office has not publicly presented evidence linking MSJP to fraudulent fundraising or terrorist financing, though Hanaway’s September announcement claimed “possible ties to fundraising for Islamic terrorists.”
The case now sits before a federal judge who will decide whether to block the demand while the lawsuit proceeds. Fossum said Hanaway could end the investigation at any time. “If Hanaway does not stop the investigation, Fossum said his team will see her in court.”
- Tennessee Tech Hosts Presbyterian Saturday With Two-Game Winning Streak
- Lake Placid Olympic Venues Serve as Drop-Off Sites for NY Holiday Donation Drive
- Trump administration moves to dismiss lawsuit over Alaska Senate race (newsarchyuk.com)
- Dollar General's Four Test Buys: 30 Price Errors, 21 Against the Shopper (daybreakwire.com)