Louisiana AG Liz Murrill Defies Judge’s Apology Directive in LSU vs SEC Case

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill announced on Wednesday, Nov. 18, that she will not comply with a federal judge’s directive to issue a public apology over language used in legal filings in the case between LSU and the SEC, Yahoo Sports reports.

Hours earlier, U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon directed LSU attorneys and the Louisiana Attorney General’s office to release a statement via email to the chamber expressing regret for using the word “hallucinated” to describe citations provided by the Southeastern Conference, according to The Tuscaloosa News. Axon told the school’s representation to make the statement “heartfelt and robust” by 3 p.m. CT.

Louisiana AG Liz Murrill refuses to apologize to SEC in ongoing player eligibility lawsuit — WDSU News

The legal dispute arose after LSU accused the conference in an Oct. 20 filing of providing either negligently sourced or “hallucinated” citations through the use of artificial intelligence, prompting the SEC to file a motion to strike.

During a 30-minute hearing in Alabama’s Northern District court, LSU lawyer Bruce Rogers ultimately conceded after Axon told him, “You put the pig out there, there’s not time to put lipstick on it,” according to reporting by AL.com.

“I cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job and it is improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the State of Louisiana,” Murrill said in a statement Wednesday, Nov. 18.

Judge tells LSU, Louisiana AG's office to apologize to SEC — WWLTV

In a letter filed in the court, Murrill argued that the compelled speech doctrine prohibits government compulsion of speech unless it satisfies strict scrutiny, maintaining that her office and LSU have a First Amendment right to free speech and zealous representation.

“Respectfully, the Court’s directive that the State of Louisiana publish a particular message and submit to the Court’s editing of that message violates basic free speech principles and does not satisfy strict scrutiny,” Murrill wrote. “As a result, my office cannot comply with this directive.”

Louisiana governor, AG refuse to comply with 'frivolous' order to apologize to SEC — WDSU News

While Murrill maintained her position that the Alabama federal court lacks jurisdiction, her office approved striking the disputed language and filed a motion to substitute the word “actually” in place of “appear to be negligently supplied or hallucinated because they” in the filing. Murrill also asked the court to relieve Rogers from the case so he would not suffer any collateral consequences.