LPL Financial closed its purchase of a $2.7 billion Commonwealth team on Friday as the platform conversion began, locking in a high-teens EBITDA multiple to stop a defections bleed that has already cut advisor headcount retention to 77.5%, Wealth Management reported.
The Axial Financial Group deal, brokered by Marshberry, caps a summer bidding war for the Massachusetts practice run by Michael Marchese and Paul Miller. LPL’s retention playbook — 10 to 50 basis points on existing assets with a seven- to 10-year clawback — kept the 30-person team from joining the exodus to Cetera, Kestra, Arakadios and independent RIA channels like Merit Financial Advisors, sources told Wealth Management.
Osaic CEO Jamie Price said the market rally has masked the true attrition. LPL shifted its public target from 90% of advisors to 90% of assets, letting 16 months of gains inflate the denominator. A Muriel Consulting tally in January showed 653 Commonwealth advisors had already left since the August 2025 acquisition announcement.
“The biggest practices not only produce the most revenue, but they’re also a treasure trove of experience and cutting-edge ideas and suggestions for the home office,” said Simon Hoyle, founder of RIA Choice and a former recruiter for Kestra and Cambridge Investment Research. “Sure, many stand to receive a windfall, but they likely committed to a long-term partnership — LPL is exceptionally good at math.”
Axial Deal Sets Valuation Ceiling
The high-teens EBITDA multiple LPL paid for Axial matches the richest offers from private-equity-backed RIA consolidators, according to people familiar with the matter.
LPL agreed to acquire Commonwealth for $2.7 billion when it oversaw roughly 3,000 advisors and $305 billion in assets. The firm now expects to retain 83% of those assets post-conversion, it said in its most recent earnings release. An exact count of converted advisors was not available as of Monday.
Conversion Friction Creates Departure Window
Advisors who spoke with Wealth Management this week described a mostly smooth transition, though some reported delays in trade execution and new account openings. The conversion weekend itself became a catalyst for departures: teams could leave before client data fully migrated and before learning LPL’s ClientWorks system.
One group, Kintra Wealth, had been preparing to join a new fee-only RIA channel inside Commonwealth. The acquisition forced a pivot; they now oversee $4.5 billion independently and are actively recruiting, Wealth Management reported.
Recruiting Momentum Shifts
“I think they got caught a little flat-footed thinking that they could do what they thought they could do, and we always thought this is going to be a tall order,” Price said.
Retention Math Versus Culture
LPL’s retention program offered 10 to 50 basis points on existing AUM with a seven- to 10-year repayment clause if the advisor departed. Publicly, the firm framed the incentives as “tailored for Commonwealth advisors, grounded in maintaining their community and industry-leading experience.”
Price argued any buyer would effectively destroy Commonwealth’s culture. Hoyle countered that LPL’s liquidity and succession program — roughly 80 deals totaling $900 million in capital — creates a structural moat: “I don’t expect Axial to be a loss leader for LPL precisely because the spillover retention and positive recruiting effect should make a worthwhile trade-off.”
“Today is a big day,” LPL CEO Rich Steinmeier wrote on LinkedIn Monday. “Commonwealth advisors have officially joined our platform. It’s one of the most important milestones in our firm’s history.”
The next marker arrives with LPL’s next quarterly earnings release, when the firm will disclose final advisor and asset retention figures for the completed conversion.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and market analysis purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. Always consult with a certified financial professional before making investment decisions.