Bancroft Claims Whole Team Knew of Sandpaper Plot, Cummins Denies Knowledge

Australian cricket’s oldest wound reopened this week when Cameron Bancroft declared the entire 2018 team knew about the sandpaper ploy in South Africa, a claim that contradicts years of denials from the current captain and his senior bowlers.

The revelation, detailed in a first-person account published by ESPN, shifts the scandal’s center of gravity from three banned individuals to the whole playing group.

Bancroft wrote that he was encouraged by then-bowling coach David Saker and received “wraps and encouragement from members of the playing and coaching staff” during the second Test at Port Elizabeth. The only dissenting voice, he said, came from media manager Kate Hutchison, who walked away after calling it wrong.

Cummins pushes back in marathon press conference

Pat Cummins, who was part of that touring party but not in the leadership group, responded on Friday with a 70-minute press conference in which he denied any knowledge of sandpaper use. According to The Guardian, Cummins called the suggestion of a wider scheme “100% wrong” and “utter nonsense,” insisting the episode was a harebrained plan escalated by a few players rather than a team-wide conspiracy.

He detailed the various ball-management techniques he had encountered in his career — including a bottle-cap incident in a Sheffield Shield game shut down by umpires — and said he had never seen sandpaper used or agreed to its use while playing for Australia.

“When he says ‘we all knew,’ if that means the whole team, that’s 100 per cent wrong,” Cummins told reporters. “I’m really glad he feels like he can, but we have to be accountable for the things that we say and do.”

Khawaja memoir ignites the latest flare-up

The current rupture traces to Usman Khawaja’s memoir, Sabr, in which he wrote that ball-tampering was commonplace and the entire team needed to take responsibility. David Warner, banned for a year alongside Bancroft and Steve Smith in 2018, backed Khawaja’s account on social media, calling it “100 per cent accurate,” ABC News reported.

Warner also criticized Cricket Australia for withholding evidence, writing on Instagram: “I was never told the bowlers had been interviewed or provided statements. That information would’ve been pretty useful when I was forced to make decisions back in 2018.”

Former teammates corroborate ‘everyone knew’

Chadd Sayers, who played his solitary Test on that 2018 tour, told SEN radio he was comfortable stating every member of the squad knew sandpaper was being used. “It was used in two Test matches and there were discussions in change rooms,” Sayers said, according to ABC News. “I’m not taking sides; it’s just the truth.”

“I received wraps and encouragement from members of the playing and coaching staff, especially David Saker. Our media manager, Kate Hutchison, expressed her objection to what was happening. I recall her making it clear that she believed it was wrong, that she wanted nothing to do with it, and walking away from the discussion. I will never forget that. Somebody had spoken up. Somebody had demonstrated that being part of the team did not mean having to accept everything the team was doing. And I ignored it.”

— Cameron Bancroft, writing for ESPN

The 2018 investigation under fresh scrutiny

Bancroft’s account raises pointed questions about Cricket Australia’s original investigation, which sanctioned only Smith, Warner, and Bancroft.

The BBC reported Bancroft’s claim that then-coach Darren Lehmann sent a message via Peter Handscomb to retrieve the sandpaper after Bancroft was caught on camera: “If he didn’t know he wouldn’t have said that. And if it wasn’t clear enough before, then it was obvious now.” Lehmann has previously denied knowledge of the specific plan.

Cricketer Chadd Sayers walks off the ground after a drinks break, wearing a cap and sunglasses
Photo: ABC News & Headlines

In 2021, Bancroft told The Guardian the bowlers’ involvement was “self-explanatory,” prompting a joint statement from Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, and Nathan Lyon denying any knowledge. “Reading that statement was deeply painful,” Bancroft wrote this week. “I had memories of conversations on the field in Port Elizabeth and Newlands, feedback about the ball and shared celebrations that made the statement difficult for me to digest.”

What remains unresolved

Cricket Australia has not announced a new inquiry. Michael Clarke said recently he wants “whatever the truth is for it all to come out, allow people to finally tell the truth, and move on. Fans have not moved on.”

Michael Clarke said he intends to participate in a CA forum to speak “as specific and detailed as possible without being general.” The governing body has not set a date for that forum.

Bancroft's bombshell article claims everyone in Australian team knew about sandpaper — ABC News (Australia)