Maui Council Confirms DesJardins as Corporation Counsel Despite 2013 Plea

The Maui County Council voted unanimously Friday to confirm Mimi DesJardins as corporation counsel and Andrew Martin to a second term as prosecuting attorney, cementing Mayor Richard Bissen’s legal team despite a contentious process that bypassed a voter-approved nomination board.

The confirmations came after DesJardins publicly addressed a 2013 no-contest plea to tampering with a government record, a charge that forced her resignation as a family court judge. “I made a terrible judgment error, and it cost me my career as a judge,” DesJardins told the council, according to Honolulu Civil Beat.

She pleaded no contest after entering incorrect times on multiple judicial probable-cause documents to keep an arrested person in custody beyond the 48-hour limit, Civil Beat reported, citing The Maui News. She was sentenced to 300 hours of community service and a $2,000 contribution to the state general fund; the conviction was kept off her record after she met court requirements for one year.

The Charter Deadline That Forced the Vote

The timing of the confirmations drew public criticism for appearing rushed before the new council is sworn in Jan. 2. Council member Keani Rawlins-Fernandez, who represents Molokaʻi, explained the mayor was legally granted unilateral appointment authority after the Independent Nomination Board missed the County Charter-prescribed deadline to submit names.

“What may look like a rush, because it’s the end of our term and before the new term, is not us rushing. It’s what the charter mandates us to do,” Rawlins-Fernandez said. “It’s unfortunate that the timeline was set up the way it was, but this is the timeline in the charter.”

Voters narrowly rejected a charter amendment introduced by Rawlins-Fernandez in the Nov. 3 election that would have dissolved the board and changed the nomination deadlines. The board was approved by voters in 2022 and established in 2024 to improve transparency around the nomination process.

DesJardins’ Decade in County Government

DesJardins has served as first deputy corporation counsel under Victoria Takayesu since 2018. Takayesu, appointed by Bissen in January 2023, intends to remain with the department as first deputy to DesJardins, council member Kauanoe Batangan confirmed Friday. The Department of Corporation Counsel employs about two dozen lawyers with two open positions.

Rawlins-Fernandez praised DesJardins’ responsiveness and her approach to separating legal advice from policymaking. “She is always super responsive and quick,” Rawlins-Fernandez said. “I really appreciate her ensuring that when she is giving advice, that she is separating legal advice, the law, and then the policy — which is our lane, which is our kuleana — and she makes sure to empower us in policymaking decisions and not interfere with that.”

Bissen highlighted DesJardins' role handling legal complexities from the 2023 wildfires and pushing post-disaster recovery initiatives forward. “She has earned my trust and confidence not only through her knowledge of the law, but through her integrity, professionalism, and thoughtful approach to some of the most difficult challenges facing our county,” he told the council.

Maui Council Confirms DesJardins as Corporation Counsel Despite 2013 Plea

Council Unanimously Reappoints Andrew Martin as Prosecutor

All nine council members voted to reappoint Andrew Martin as prosecuting attorney. Martin has prosecuted high-profile cases including the fatal shooting of Maui Police Officer Suzanne O and a Lahaina man convicted of 16 counts of sexual assault against a child. “That wasn’t a political statement,” Martin said.

“It was a statement to set the record straight. Had I not corrected that statement, to be honest, I would have felt like a coward, and that I wasn’t doing the right thing, so I issued the statement. It speaks for itself as to the independence of the prosecutor’s office and the work that we do.”

Council Chair Alice Lee expressed reservations about Martin’s handling of a lawsuit filed by former Bissen chief of staff Leo Caires, who sued the county in April alleging retaliation after raising concerns about potential fraud and financial mismanagement. “I do support him overall. I think his performance has been overall good,” Lee said, adding she did not like how he handled that lawsuit.

Maui County spans the islands of Maui, Lānaʻi, Molokaʻi (except for a portion that comprises Kalawao County), Kahoʻolawe, and Molokini, with a 2020 population of 164,754 and a total area of 2,398 square miles, more than half of it water. The county operates under a quasi-mayor-council system established by state statute, not a charter, with a nine-member council elected at-large on a nonpartisan basis to two-year terms.

The new council will be sworn in Jan. 2.