Mays Pitches Jets Trade for Colts Coach Shane Steichen

It is idea season for the New York Jets, that desperate stretch where a 2-8 record invites every imaginable fix, but the latest suggestion — trading a first-round pick for Indianapolis Colts coach Shane Steichen — ignores the reality that Steichen is a lame duck coach presiding over a 4-16 slide across his last 20 games.

Robert Mays of The Athletic Football Show pitched the swap this week, arguing the Jets should send the Dallas Cowboys’ 2027 first-rounder — acquired in the November 4, 2025, trade for Quinnen Williams — to Indianapolis for a coach the Colts appear ready to fire.

“That pick is probably going to end up as like the 17th or 18th pick in the draft,” Mays said. “I don’t think Shane Steichen is worth firing, and he is under contract, but I do think it’s worth moving on from him.”

The Colts entered the weekend 3-8 after a 26-3 throttling by the Houston Texans on Thursday night, managing just 167 yards of offense. Steichen owns a 45.2 win percentage in four seasons; his offenses have ranked in the top half of the league in scoring just twice, and this year sits 26th.

Mays Pitches Jets Trade for Colts Coach Shane Steichen
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

“One of the worst takes you will hear regarding the Jets’ search for a head coach. How are people like this paid to talk about football? Mind-blowing.”

an X user reacting to Mays’ proposal

Jeremy Fowler added context Friday, reporting the Colts view Steichen as a potential “lame duck situation” and that the front office wanted to see a win or two against Minnesota and Jacksonville before finalizing plans. Bleacher Report relayed Fowler’s assessment that the Colts “value him” but the window to save his job was narrowing rapidly.

The Jets’ own coaching uncertainty

New York’s interest in any coach stems from Aaron Glenn’s struggles in Year 2. The Jets sit 2-8, owners of the NFL’s longest active playoff drought, and Glenn’s game management has drawn scrutiny.

Fowler reported that Woody Johnson remains “really happy with Aaron Glenn as a whole as far as the progress they made in the offseason from Year 1 to Year 2,” but acknowledged clock management issues make this “a job to watch now.” The Jets finished 3-14 in Glenn’s debut 2025 campaign, starting 0-7.

Why the Steichen math collapses

Indianapolis holds the advantage: if they fire Steichen, he hits the open market without compensation. Mays placed his confidence in the idea at 55 percent, but the Colts’ offensive collapse — 30th in PFN’s Team Impact Score grading — undercuts the label that made Steichen a candidate in the first place.

“There are three coaches I’d trade a first for. Kyle Shanahan, Sean McVay, Ben Johnson. And only if I had a franchise QB and roster ready to compete.”

another X user responding to the proposal

The asset the Jets actually control

The Jets’ next three games — Las Vegas, Kansas City, Buffalo — will likely decide Glenn’s fate before any coaching search begins in earnest.

His play-calling roots trace to Los Angeles, where he guided Justin Herbert to Offensive Rookie of the Year honors in 2020 and oversaw a Chargers offense that ranked sixth in passing yards.

A former UNLV quarterback who once tied a school record with five touchdown passes in a single game, Steichen got his NFL start as a defensive assistant under Norv Turner in San Diego before Turner brought him to Cleveland as an offensive quality control coach in 2013.

Dolphins jets football
Photo: bleacherreport.com

Indianapolis faces Jacksonville this week. Another loss likely seals Steichen’s exit and renders the trade debate moot.