The Minneapolis City Council voted to deny the confirmation of Billy Peterson as the city’s permanent police chief.
This decision leaves the Minneapolis Police Department (MPD) without a confirmed leader and creates a vacancy that could take up to a year to fill through a new nomination, vetting, and confirmation process.
The split within the council
While the DSA voting bloc on the Council was expected to oppose the nomination, the votes of Council Members Vetaw and Warren have drawn scrutiny.
The Minneapolis Times reports that the DSA-aligned city council’s vote may be among its most destructive actions, potentially damaging cooperation between the mayor and the council, destroying police morale, and making it difficult to find a successor with qualifications equal to those of Peterson.
According to the DSA party platform, the group aims to “defund the police by rejecting any expansion to police budgets or scope of enforcement while cutting budgets annually toward zero.”
Council Member Vetaw stated her preference for Charlie Adams, a highly regarded police executive, as the preferred choice for the role. Critics argue that the Council’s role is to examine the qualifications of the actual nominee rather than to nominate their own candidates.
Council Member Warren’s reasoning was less explicit. Rather than citing specific professional failures, Warren appeared to suggest that Peterson required more personal self‑improvement. This sentiment was delivered despite testimony indicating that Peterson’s 31‑year career includes approximately 30 commendations and zero sustained complaints.
Possible way forward
One suggested strategy is for Mayor Frey to veto the Council’s denial; the Council would then vote to override the veto, but the source indicates that the override would likely fail. Afterward, the mayor could renominate Peterson for confirmation.