In a column for The Athletic, Austin Mock argues that stripping away team names and relying solely on metrics produces a playoff picture that looks markedly different from the committee’s weekly rankings.
Mock presented eight anonymous resumes to a colleague, asking for a top-four ranking based strictly on strength of schedule, strength of record, records against winning teams, and point differentials. The exercise, published Monday, placed Wake Forest and Texas Tech ahead of Oregon, BYU, and Tennessee — teams currently sitting higher in the official CFP standings.
“I believe in the committee’s approach to assessing teams at their best more than their worst,” the evaluator wrote of Team G, later revealed as Texas Tech. “Who a team beats tells you much more about that team — and what it would be in the College Football Playoff — than who gives that team a loss.”
The blind test also flagged Oregon (Team D) as a difficult case: three losses but five wins over winning teams and a 69 percent opponent win percentage that somehow translated to only the 13th-ranked strength of schedule. “That seems impossible,” the evaluator said.
The resumes covered teams with records ranging from 7-3 to 9-1. Strength of schedule varied wildly, from 9 (Team F, later revealed as Ohio State) to 66 (Team G, Texas Tech). Strength of record — a measure of how difficult a team’s record is to achieve — ranked Team C (Wake Forest) eighth nationally despite a schedule strength of 44.
| Metric | Team C (Wake Forest) | Team G (Texas Tech) | Team D (Oregon) | Team A (BYU) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Record | 9-1 | 9-1 | 7-3 | 8-2 |
| Strength of Schedule | 44 | 66 | 13 | 39 |
| Strength of Record | 8 | 11 | 17 | 16 |
| vs. CFP Top 25 | 1-1 | 2-0 | 3-1 | 2-1 |
| Avg. Point Differential | 23.6 | 13.7 | 5.3 | 7.3 |
Wake Forest’s average point differential of 23.6 led the group by a wide margin. Texas Tech posted a 2-0 mark against the CFP Top 25 with zero games against the Top 10. Oregon’s three losses came against a gauntlet: eight winning opponents and four Top 25 teams.
The weekend’s results reshaped the SEC’s playoff outlook. Five conference teams saw their playoff hopes effectively eliminated in a single weekend. Ole Miss saw its chances plummet from 42 percent to under 1 percent after a rain-soaked loss to Oklahoma. LSU’s odds dropped from 30 percent to under 1 percent following a loss to Texas. Kentucky fell from 29 percent to 7 percent after losing to Florida.
“Only four SEC teams have a better than 12 percent chance to make the field,” it was written.