Montana Senate Leaders to Refer Sen. Windy Boy to Ethics Committee in January

Montana Senate leaders from both parties announced Wednesday they will refer Sen. Jonathan Windy Boy, D-Box Elder, to the Senate Ethics Committee when the 2027 Legislature convenes in January, following allegations of sexual misconduct that include claims involving minors, Daily Montanan reported.

Senate President-elect Matt Regier, R-Kalispell, and Senate Minority Leader Laura Smith, D-Helena, issued a joint statement confirming the formal inquiry and the formation of a four-member Ethics Committee. The move marks a rare moment of bipartisan alignment in a chamber often defined by partisan friction, and it shows that the Legislature intends to use its Ethics Committee against a lawmaker who has served continuously since 2003.

“We are confident that the formal Ethics Committee process will provide Senator Windy Boy with the due process that he deserves and also resolve this situation with any investigation into the facts and accountability measures that are deemed appropriate,” the leaders said in their joint statement. “We are working together across party lines to address the allegations with the seriousness that this situation demands.”

The allegations surfaced this spring while Windy Boy was running in the Democratic primary for Montana’s eastern U.S. House district. The state Democratic Party said it had been made aware of “severe sexual abuse allegations” that included sending explicit photos and messages to underage girls two decades ago.

Brian Miller, an attorney who ran against Windy Boy for the congressional nomination, told the outlet he was representing a victim. Windy Boy has denied the accusations, calling them a “political ambush” and a “coordinated political smear” in a press release posted to his now-defunct campaign website. He has not spoken to the press since the legislative announcement Wednesday.

Jonathan Windy Boy
Photo: krtv.com

A pattern of substantiated complaints

In 2017, an investigation by the Legislative Services Division substantiated claims that he sent harassing text messages to then-Sen. Jen Gross, who identified herself as the victim earlier this year, Daily Montanan reported. That complaint resulted in a formal reprimand but did not remove him from office.

The current allegations, however, are of a different magnitude. They include claims of sending explicit photos and messages to underage girls two decades ago. The Montana Democratic Party called for his resignation in April and reiterated that demand Wednesday.

“People who report sexual misconduct deserve to be heard and to know they can speak up without fear of retaliation,” party Chair Bruce Knutson said in a statement. “Montanans deserve to know we’ll hold a member of our own party to the same standard we’d expect of anyone else.”

Stripped of power pending inquiry

While the Ethics Committee prepares to convene, legislative leaders have already moved to sideline Windy Boy. Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, chairman of the committee that assigns committee memberships, confirmed Wednesday that Windy Boy will not be appointed to any committee positions for the upcoming session. “We chose not to reappoint him to any positions of power until the Ethics Committee can complete its work,” Glimm said.

In May, the Senate voted to remove him from interim committees, and 40 of the 50 state senators — a supermajority spanning both parties — signed a letter urging him to resign, KRTV reported. He refused. Last week, Windy Boy participated in the caucus meeting in Helena where Smith was elected minority leader, a presence that highlighted the awkward limbo of a duly elected senator facing expulsion proceedings.

Montana Senate Leaders to Refer Sen. Windy Boy to Ethics Committee in January
Photo: fairfieldsuntimes.com

“I think everyone in our caucus recognizes the seriousness of the allegations. As a former prosecutor, I recognize the seriousness of the allegations,” Smith told reporters last week. “But she added that until the Ethics Committee is convened, investigates and reports back to the Senate, Windy Boy remains a duly elected official.”

The mechanics of accountability

The Ethics Committee for the 2027 session will comprise Sens. Forrest Mandeville, R-Columbus, Amy Regier, R-Kalispell, Christopher Pope, D-Bozeman, and Erin Farris-Olsen, D-Helena.

Mandeville and Pope served on the committee during the 2025 inquiry into former Senate President Jason Ellsworth, R-Hamilton, who was ultimately stripped of all official duties and privileges following an investigation into abuse of power. That process stretched from a Jan. 25 referral to an April 1 vote — roughly half the session, KRTV noted.

Regier said leadership has proposed new procedures for ethics inquiries this session, which will be vetted by rules committees in the coming weeks. “We didn’t have that framework last session,” Regier said. “So it’ll depend what Joint Rules does with it, but I thought it was a fairly good ethics process, so that I’m assuming will make things smoother — I don’t know if it’ll make it faster.”

If the committee recommends discipline or expulsion, a two-thirds vote of the full Senate would be required. Should Windy Boy resign or be removed, his replacement would be chosen by a board of county commissioners from the six counties comprising Senate District 16, drawing nominees from local Democratic Central Committees.

The political calculus

Smith, a former prosecutor, and Regier, a conservative Republican, have framed the inquiry as a matter of institutional integrity rather than partisan warfare.

The specific allegations have not been made public by the Democratic Party, and no criminal charges have been filed. Windy Boy has emphasized that previous claims were investigated and resulted in no criminal prosecution. In 2025, an ethics inquiry into Sen. Jason Ellsworth spread over roughly half the legislative session and resulted in Ellsworth being stripped of all official duties and privileges.

The Ethics Committee will convene in January 2027.