N.J. Supreme Court Reinstates $562,500 Verdict Against Newark: Mandatory Low-Clearance Signs Not Subject to Discretionary Immunity

The New Jersey Supreme Court reinstated a $562,500 jury verdict against the City of Newark on Thursday, ruling that a state law requiring warning signs for low-clearance bridges strips municipalities of the discretionary immunity that usually shields them from tort claims.

Justice Rachel Wainer Apter, writing for a unanimous court, held that signs mandated by N.J.S.A. 27:5G-4 are not “ordinary traffic signals” under the Tort Claims Act because public entities have no choice about whether to post them. The decision reverses an Appellate Division ruling that had dismissed David and Cheryl Wilson’s lawsuit over a 2015 crash on Avenue P.

“There is no discretion,” the Court wrote, quoting the statute’s directive that municipalities shall mark every bridge under 14 feet 6 inches and post a separate warning at the last safe exit. Because the duty is mandatory, the immunity in N.J.S.A. 59:4-5 — which applies only to discretionary decisions about “ordinary” signs — does not attach.

Truck Struck Low Overpass Lacking Required Height Warnings

David Wilson was driving a 13-foot-6-inch tractor-trailer for Performance Food Group on the morning of March 26, 2015, when he turned onto Avenue P following a sign marked “truck route.” The railroad overpass there clears only 12 feet 2 inches. Wilson’s trailer wedged beneath the bridge; he suffered a neck injury that later required surgery.

At trial, the Wilsons introduced evidence that no height marker was posted on the overpass itself and no advance warning sign stood at the last safe detour point — both required by the 1986 statute.

A maintenance worker testified that Newark maintains roughly 350 road miles and tens of thousands of traffic signs. The City had produced work orders showing the Avenue P height sign had been knocked down and reinstalled multiple times, most recently in February 2015, just weeks before the crash.

The jury found the City liable under N.J.S.A. 59:4-2, determining its failure to maintain the mandated signs created a dangerous condition and that the City’s inaction was “palpably unreasonable.” It awarded David Wilson $562,500; Cheryl Wilson’s loss-of-consortium claim resulted in a no-cause verdict.

Appellate Division vs. Supreme Court

A three-judge Appellate Division panel reversed in May 2025, holding that Wilson failed to prove the City created the dangerous condition or had actual or constructive notice of the missing sign. The panel concluded the City was entitled to immunity under N.J.S.A. 59:4-5 as a matter of law.

The Supreme Court disagreed. It traced the legislative history of N.J.S.A. 27:5G-4, enacted after a series of bridge strikes, and emphasized the statute’s mandatory language: “The Commissioner shall require… the municipal or county authority shall erect and maintain.”

That command, the Court said, removes the discretion that underpins the immunity in Civalier v. Estate of Trancucci, 138 N.J. 52 (1994), where the Court held public entities immune for failing to install optional traffic signals.

“The City’s violation of N.J.S.A. 27:5G-4(b) does not on its own create liability. For plaintiffs to prevail, they must have presented sufficient evidence at trial for the jury to find the City liable under 59:4-2. The jury specifically found that the City’s actions or non-actions [were] palpably unreasonable.”

— Justice Rachel Wainer Apter, David B. Wilson v. City of Newark, A-21-25 (Nov. 19, 2026)

The Court also rejected the City’s argument that placing the advance-warning sign at a different location — still within the City’s right-of-way — was a discretionary planning decision immune from suit. The statute, the opinion notes, requires the sign at the “last safe exit or detour,” leaving no room for municipal judgment about placement.

What this means for municipalities

The ruling clarifies that when the Legislature imposes a non-discretionary duty to install specific safety signage, the Tort Claims Act’s sign-immunity provision does not apply. Cities and counties must now treat low-clearance bridge warnings as ministerial obligations — akin to maintaining a stop sign once installed — rather than discretionary traffic-engineering choices.

For truckers and commercial carriers, the decision reinforces the expectation that posted truck routes will be vetted for vertical clearance. For Newark, which argued its 350-mile sign inventory made constant monitoring impractical, the verdict stands as a costly reminder that statutory mandates override resource constraints.

Justice Rachel Wainer Apter, who grew up in Rockaway and graduated from Morris Hills High School, clerked for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg after earlier clerkships in the Southern District of New York and the Second Circuit.

She later served as director of the New Jersey Division on Civil Rights and as counsel to the Attorney General, where she led a team defending the DACA program. Governor Phil Murphy nominated her in March 2021; after an initial nomination expired, she was renominated in January 2022, confirmed by a 23–14 Senate vote in October 2022, and sworn in on October 21, 2022.

The case returns to the Law Division for entry of judgment on the reinstated verdict.