“This disaster was not an unavoidable accident. It was a systematic failure that could have been completely avoided if basic safety regulations and rigorous oversight was strictly followed,” said Michael Johnson, vice chair of the New York Communities for Change Flatbush Chapter. A week after a three-story building collapsed onto a neighboring construction site on Flatbush Avenue, killing eight people and injuring 18, residents and advocates gathered Wednesday night to mourn the dead and demand accountability.
The collapse on November 18 left a scar on the neighborhood that goes beyond the rubble. Among the dead were two children and Edgar Sapon Gutierrez, a 26-year-old construction worker whose sister, Elizabeth Vasquez, told CBS News New York he left behind a wife and a 6-year-old son.
“He’s a good man. He work. He don’t have any problem with anybody,” Vasquez said. “She don’t have anybody for help for baby, and she don’t have nothing for home, food, and she need it. Please, can somebody help for her?”
Speakers at the vigil drew a direct line from the disaster to a history of lax enforcement. Renette Bradley, a tenant organizer with HOPE, pointed to the building’s landlord, who she said was arrested for being a slumlord in 2006. “There’s no reason why a landlord that had been arrested for being a slumlord in 2006 was able to come out and still be a slum landlord,” Bradley said.
Cheryl John of SEIU 1199 added, “You had sanctions, you paid $10,000, you cut a corner, and you disregarded whatever safety guards they told you to have in place.” Michael Piccirillo of the NYC District Council of Carpenters framed it bluntly: “This is an example of what happens when you put profits over people, right here.”
The Department of Buildings announced Wednesday that 1323 Flatbush Ave., the building left exposed by the collapse, must be demolished. Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said in a statement that the damage is so severe that stabilizing it would endanger workers. “Unfortunately, allowing workers into the building to do the necessary heavy-duty shoring needed to stabilize the building would put those workers at risk,” Tigani said.
“Given the dangerous condition of the building and the imperative to make sure no one else gets hurt, ordering for the controlled safe demolition of the building is the only available option.” The DOB added it is too dangerous to allow anyone inside to retrieve belongings.

Displacement is compounding the grief. The Red Cross registered 47 people, including 11 children, for emergency assistance; 41 are in temporary housing. An emergency resource hub at a nearby YMCA has been dismantled, and officials directed displaced residents to contact the Red Cross and HPD’s Emergency Housing Services. Meanwhile, volunteers at Bethesda Church of God across the street have been accepting donations of clothing, toiletries, and toys around the clock.
“Sometimes we’re leaving at like 2, 3 in the morning, but yeah, we’ve just opened up our spot every single day for people to just come and donate,” volunteer Yvicha Dupres told CBS News New York. “This is all the community. They came out. They showed up for these people.”
Councilwoman Farrah Louis called on the mayor’s office to enact an immediate moratorium on new construction within Community Board 17. “Just a pause to just help us take a step back on what’s currently happening, what applications are in, and for us to do a review on who is trying to build in this district,” Louis said.
She also asked the DOB and the Department of Housing Preservation and Development to turn over inspection records for the area.
After the vigil, marchers walked Flatbush Avenue chanting for union-built housing and tenant ownership. “This is our neighborhood. This is our fight. We want our homes built by union labor workers. People who care about our safety. We want good landlords. We want to be our own damn landlords,” Bradley said.
New York Communities for Change formed in 2010 after the national group ACORN dissolved, with Jon Kest, its former New York lead organizer, as founder. Jonathan Westin has served as executive director since 2012, following Kest’s death. The 501(c)(4) nonprofit organizes low-income New Yorkers on housing, education and wages.
Amid the loss, a small reunion offered a moment of relief. A child named Zariah Coleman had been searching for her cat, Isaac, since the collapse. Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Sunday that Isaac was found alive after four days without food or water and is receiving veterinary care, CBS News New York reported. Coleman was set to reunite with her pet Monday afternoon.