Napheesa Collier, Kayla Thornton, and Maggie Doogan Are Potential Indiana Fever Targets

The Indiana Fever face a defining roster crossroads as they weigh the future of forward Sophie Cunningham.

Decisions made during this off-season will likely dictate whether the franchise can transition from a rising talent pool to a legitimate championship contender.

Controversy has surrounded Cunningham’s role within the organization throughout 2026, leaving the front office with a difficult choice regarding her contract renewal. According to Indiana Fever On SI, if the franchise decides not to re-sign the forward, several free-agent profiles emerge that align with the team’s long-term championship vision.

The stakes extend beyond simple roster spots. For a team built around the gravity of Caitlin Clark and the interior presence of Aliyah Boston, finding the right tactical fit is a necessity rather than a luxury. The Fever must balance immediate defensive needs with the financial flexibility required to build a sustainable winner.

If Indiana chooses to prioritize a superstar upgrade, Napheesa Collier stands as the premier unrestricted free agent available. The Minnesota Lynx forward has established herself as a needle-moving talent capable of impacting the game on both ends of the floor. Throughout her career, Collier has maintained impressive averages of 18.2 points, 7.8 rebounds, 1.7 steals, and 1.2 blocks per game.

Napheesa Collier, Kayla Thornton, and Maggie Doogan Are Potential Indiana Fever Targets

Acquiring Collier would fundamentally alter the Fever’s defensive identity. By absorbing significant defensive responsibilities, she would provide much-needed relief for Aliyah Boston, allowing the center to focus on offensive production and rim protection. However, a move for Collier would likely require a large financial commitment, potentially necessitating the decision not to re-sign Kelsey Mitchell to maintain the necessary cap space.

For a more direct replacement of Cunningham’s specific skill set, the Fever could look toward Kayla Thornton. Coming off a championship season with the Golden State Valkyries, the 34-year-old forward offers a level of veteran leadership that Indiana currently lacks. Thornton is recognized as a selfless player who provides reliable spot-up shooting from the perimeter.

During the regular season, Thornton averaged 34.7 percent from 3-point range, a figure that climbed to 36.8 percent during the playoffs. Beyond the shooting, her background with a Golden State franchise that prioritizes high-intensity defensive effort could address the Fever’s well-documented struggles on that end of the court. Her presence would serve to hold younger teammates accountable to the defensive standards required for postseason success.

A more economical but potentially brilliant piece of business involves Maggie Doogan. The 22-year-old forward is currently playing for Baxi Ferrol in Spain after going undrafted in 2026 and failing to secure a spot with the Phoenix Mercury. Doogan represents a high-upside prospect who could flourish when paired with an elite playmaker like Caitlin Clark.

Doogan’s collegiate production at Richmond was characterized by remarkable efficiency and scoring outbursts. During her senior year, she averaged 21.1 points, 7.9 rebounds, and 3.9 assists per game, while shooting 50.6 percent from the floor and 40.4 percent from deep.

Her ability to handle high-volume scoring was most evident on January 10, when she became the first player in Atlantic 10 history to score 48 points, leading the Spiders to a 91-84 triple-overtime victory over Davidson, as reported by Indiana Fever On SI.

Player	Primary Role/Trait	Key Statistical Profile
Napheesa Collier	Two-way Superstar	18.2 PPG, 7.8 RPG, 1.7 SPG
Kayla Thornton	Veteran 3-Point Specialist	34.7% 3PT (Regular Season)
Maggie Doogan	High-Efficiency Prospect	50.6% FG, 40.4% 3PT

The decision rests on whether the Fever seek to maximize their current window with a superstar or build depth through efficient, low-cost contributors. The upcoming free agency period will reveal which path the front office believes is most viable for the franchise’s evolution.

Keep reading