New Mexico AG Joins Motion for Statewide Injunction Halting 7-Day Gun Wait

New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez agreed Wednesday to a statewide injunction halting enforcement of the state’s seven-day waiting period for firearm purchases, effectively conceding a legal fight his office had pressed for months after a federal appeals court already declared the law unconstitutional.

The joint motion, filed in U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico in NSSF v. Torrez, asks Magistrate Judge Jerry H. Ritter to bar the attorney general and everyone under his supervision from implementing House Bill 129 while the underlying Second Amendment challenge proceeds, NRA-ILA reported.

The injunction would stay in force unless the Tenth Circuit reverses its own decision in Ortega v. Grisham and issues a final mandate upholding the waiting period.

That earlier ruling is the engine driving the current settlement. In Ortega, a three-judge panel of the Tenth Circuit held last year that the seven-day delay violated the Second Amendment and directed the district court to enter an injunction.

When that judgment was formalized, however, Torrez maintained the law remained binding on every other New Mexican and every gun dealer in the state because the relief applied only to the two individual plaintiffs in that case, Bearing Arms reported.

“The state continued to enforce the law against all New Mexicans except the individual plaintiffs in Ortega,” the NRA-ILA filing says, describing a gap between the appellate mandate and the executive branch’s compliance that prompted the second lawsuit.

New Mexico AG Joins Motion for Statewide Injunction Halting 7-Day Gun Wait
Photo: bearingarms.com

The new plaintiff coalition is expansive: the National Rifle Association, the National Shooting Sports Foundation, the Second Amendment Foundation, the New Mexico Firearms Industry Association, the New Mexico Shooting Sports Association, two firearms retailers — Calibers Shooting Sports Center and Omni Tactical USA — the advocacy group Right to Bear Arms, and NRA member Peter Hackett.

Their argument was straightforward: the Constitution does not permit a patchwork of rights depending on who filed the first lawsuit.

Torrez’s pivot is striking. For months he insisted the Ortega injunction was narrow and that House Bill 129 remained good law statewide. Wednesday’s stipulation abandons that position without the attorney general admitting the statute is unconstitutional. The motion simply acknowledges the Tenth Circuit has already ruled against the waiting period and that the state faces near-certain defeat if it continues litigating the scope of relief plaintiff by plaintiff.

Bearing Arms, analyzing the strategic shift, suggested Torrez and his counsel likely concluded they were fighting a losing battle against a growing docket of challengers. “Even if he managed to defeat the latest lawsuit on procedural grounds, the underlying constitutional issue doesn’t disappear,” the outlet observed.

102126 gc EpsteinPressConference06rgb.jpg
Photo: santafenewmexican.com

Indeed, the Firearms Policy Coalition filed a separate federal suit Wednesday morning challenging the same enforcement posture. That case will likely be mooted if Ritter signs the stipulated order, which both parties expect will happen as a formality given their agreement.

The practical effect is immediate once the judge enters the order: any New Mexican who passes a background check can take possession of a firearm the same day, restoring the status quo that existed before the 2023 legislative session enacted the waiting period.

The law had required a seven-business-day delay between the initiation of a background check and the transfer of the firearm, a provision sponsors framed as a cooling-off period to reduce impulsive violence and suicides.

Gun-control advocates have warned that removing the delay eliminates a proven suicide-prevention tool. Research cited during the legislative debate indicated that waiting periods correlate with reductions in firearm homicides and suicides, though the Tenth Circuit majority found the historical-analog test required by New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen was not satisfied by the state’s proffered evidence.

The stipulated injunction is not a final judgment on the merits. The Ortega appeal remains pending before the Tenth Circuit, and the state has not withdrawn its defense of the statute. If the appellate court reverses course on rehearing or en banc review and upholds the law, the injunction dissolves automatically under the terms of the joint motion.

For now, the agreement aligns the enforcement reality with the appellate ruling that has been on the books for months. “The proposed injunction isn’t the final word on the waiting period’s fate,” Bearing Arms said, “but it should finally put every other gun buyer on the same footing as the two plaintiffs in Ortega who successfully challenged it in court.”

The next step is Ritter’s signature. The magistrate judge has not set a timeline, but with no opposition from either side, entry of the order is expected within days.