New York’s Renter Tax Credit Reform Leaves Low-Income Tenants Behind

Manhattan CPA Myung Keon Kim argues in a column that New York’s efforts to reform renter tax credits have addressed only half of a broken system.

While recent legislative actions in Albany have successfully updated income eligibility rules, a decades-old freeze on rent caps continues to disqualify the very people the policy was designed to protect, Kim writes.

The central failure lies in a single, stagnant figure: a $450 monthly rent limit that has remained unchanged since at least 2000. Under current state law, if a tenant’s average monthly rent exceeds this threshold, they receive nothing from the real property tax circuit breaker credit, regardless of how little they earn.

The gap between policy and reality

The logic of a circuit breaker credit is to offset the indirect property taxes that landlords pass on to tenants through rent. New York law treats 25 percent of a tenant’s rent as their share of property tax, offering a credit when that cost becomes too high relative to income.

However, the math behind the current cap appears disconnected from the modern economy. The $450 limit closely mirrors a calculation where rent is set at 30 percent of a $18,000 annual income—a level federal standards already consider affordable. For a modern renter, this cap effectively shuts out anyone whose rent is higher than a rate already deemed “affordable” by federal benchmarks.

The impact of this disconnect is visible in the state’s own historical data. According to records from the state’s open data catalog, the number of New York City renters claiming this credit has fallen significantly over the last quarter-century.

Metric Tax Year 2000 Tax Year 2024
NYC Renter Claims 185,320 93,882
Total Statewide Claims 298,736 114,413

In New York City, claims dropped by 49 percent, while total claims statewide plummeted by 62 percent during that period. Kim notes that while raw statistics cannot tell us the individual story behind every missing claimant, the decline aligns with the period during which the two numbers that determine eligibility stayed locked in place.

A step forward meets a closed door

Albany moved toward reform in the 2025-26 state budget. Previously, the state counted Social Security payments toward the strict $18,000 income limit, which often disqualified elderly residents living on fixed incomes.

The new budget fix aligns the income test with federal adjusted gross income (AGI). Because federal law does not tax Social Security, a retiree with a $24,000 Social Security income might now show a federal AGI of zero, passing the income test perfectly. Yet, as Kim observes, if that same retiree pays more than $450 a month in rent, the door is slammed shut by the outdated rent cap.

The credit could provide up to $375 a year—real money for someone on a fixed budget—but the current structure ensures many qualify for the income portion only to be disqualified by the rent portion.

Kim argues that a tax credit designed for low-income renters is ineffective if it is mathematically impossible for those renters to use it.

Two bills face expiration dates in the legislature

Two specific pieces of legislation are currently attempting to bridge this gap, but they face a looming expiration date. Assembly Bill A7652, sponsored by Assemblymember Steve Stern, seeks to raise the rent cap from $450 to $1,000. Meanwhile, Senate Bill S1147, sponsored by Sen. Andrew Gounardes, proposes a separate credit specifically for New York City renters with no rent cap at all.

Both bills are currently held in committee—Ways and Means in the Assembly and Budget and Revenue in the Senate. If they are not passed, both bills will officially die when the current two-year legislative term concludes on Dec. 31.

To prevent the credit from freezing for another generation, Kim suggests that lawmakers must do three things: raise the rent cap to reflect current baseline housing costs, tie the cap to a reliable cost-of‑living index, and ensure the 2025 budget fix regarding Social Security is preserved.

The latter is a critical distinction, as the older version of A7652 would have reverted to an income test that counts Social Security, despite offering a much higher $100,000 income limit.

The next opportunity for meaningful change rests with the upcoming state budget deliberations.