A single-family home on Wall Street changed hands for $999,999 last month, topping the list of the ten priciest residential deals recorded in Newark during the week of November 9,nj.com reported.
The transaction, which closed on October 21, highlights a market where the average sale price across 53 recorded deals hit $535,570 — roughly $197 per square foot. That average masks a wide spread: the ten highest sales ranged from $810,000 to just shy of $1 million, with price-per-foot figures swinging from $158 to $248 depending on vintage, layout and neighborhood.
What the top ten tell us
The Wall Street property, a 4,902-square-foot building constructed in 1910, fetched $204 per square foot. It carries 11 bedrooms and four bathrooms — a scale that suggests multifamily use or rooming-house history rather than a traditional single-family layout.
By contrast, the smallest footprint in the top tier — 88 Manchester Place at 2,284 square feet — commanded the highest per-foot price at $372. Built in 1959, it sold for $850,000 on October 26. The buyer paid a premium for a tighter, post-war single-family home on a quiet residential block.
Newer construction generally traded at lower per-foot numbers. The 5,472-square-foot house at 26-28 Mount Pleasant Avenue, built in 2010, went for $875,000 — $160 per foot. The 5,356-square-foot condo at 26 Clinton Place, Unit 28, a 2007 build, closed at $848,000 ($158 per foot). Buyers appear to discount larger, modern layouts relative to scarce, well-maintained older stock on smaller lots.
| Address | Type | Sale Price | Sq. Ft. | $/Sq. Ft. | Year Built | Deed Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 36 Wall St., Unit 38 | Multifamily | $999,999 | 4,902 | $204 | 1910 | Oct. 21 |
| 26-28 Mount Pleasant Ave. | Single-family | $875,000 | 5,472 | $160 | 2010 | Oct. 26 |
| 92 E. Bigelow St. | Single-family | $865,000 | 4,924 | $176 | 2004 | Oct. 28 |
| 88 Manchester Pl. | Single-family | $850,000 | 2,284 | $372 | 1959 | Oct. 26 |
| 284 N. 12th St., Unit 286 | Condo | $850,000 | 3,456 | $246 | 1930 | Oct. 26 |
| 91-93 Chadwick Ave. | Single-family | $850,000 | 5,002 | $170 | 2006 | Oct. 19 |
| 26 Clinton Pl., Unit 28 | Condo | $848,000 | 5,356 | $158 | 2007 | Oct. 22 |
| 200 Eastern Pkwy., Unit 202 | Condo | $840,000 | 3,600 | $233 | 1932 | Oct. 23 |
| 235 4th St. | Single-family | $820,000 | 3,444 | $238 | 2001 | Oct. 26 |
| 19 Montrose St. | Single-family | $810,000 | 3,268 | $248 | 1923 | Oct. 20 |
Inventory context
Fifty-three deeds were recorded in the week ending November 9, a pace that suggests roughly a few thousand transactions annually if sustained. The $535,570 average is pulled down by dozens of sales well below the top tier — many in the range that never appear on “most expensive” lists but constitute the bulk of market activity.
“When rates jump a half-point in a month, you see a clustering of closings right before lock expirations,” said Maria Gonzalez, a closing attorney at a Newark firm who handles 15 to 20 residential deals a month. “Sellers who priced aggressively in September still found buyers, but the negotiation window tightened.”
The counterweight
Not every high-end deal pencils out for the buyer. The Wall Street property’s 11-bedroom configuration likely requires conversion costs — fire-code upgrades, separate utilities, egress windows — that can run substantially before the first rent check arrives. Investors betting on rooming-house cash flow need occupancy rates above 85 percent to service debt at current rates, a threshold that Newark’s seasonal rental market doesn’t always guarantee.