A New Hampshire circuit court judge is facing six ethics charges from the Judicial Conduct Committee following a disputed family court proceeding in Milford, according to charges filed by the JCC, WMUR reported.
The proceedings center on 9th Circuit Court Judge Todd Prevett and his handling of a December 2024 guardianship case where a mother sought to restore her parental rights regarding a child placed with relatives nearly a decade prior, nhpr.org reported. Committee documents state that Prevett denied the request by citing out-of-state criminal cases from more than a decade ago without explaining their legal relevance to the current reunification attempt.
Investigators allege that Prevett conducted his own background research into the mother using an online court portal to examine Massachusetts records that were never entered as evidence during the hearings. The New Hampshire Judicial Conduct Committee said that Prevett’s written ruling displayed hostility and disdain, describing the parent in the order as callous, snide, and immature.

The mother subsequently appealed the decision to the state Supreme Court, which overturned the ruling, removed Prevett from the matter, and reassigned a new judge to the case. Carol Erskine, a retired Massachusetts juvenile court judge, told WMUR that appellate interventions of this nature are highly unusual.
“It’s exceptionally rare for an appellate decision from a state Supreme Court to overturn a judge with an order to assign a new judge based on bias and [partiality],” Erskine said.
Erskine added that the current JCC complaint is thoroughly documented and leaves the judge with a difficult defense. Prevett filed a self-report in October 2024 that transitioned into a formal investigation a month later, resulting in charges alleging violations of codes requiring fair, impartial, and unbiased performance of judicial duties.
This inquiry follows a previous disciplinary matter from 2024 involving a formal reprimand, according to WMUR and nhpr.org. In that instance, Prevett admitted to improperly identifying himself to a security guard as a judge from another district and asking for a favor to enter a closed courthouse in Concord to file paperwork for his own personal guardianship case.
Following the 2024 reprimand, Prevett was ordered to receive mentorship from a senior circuit court judge. In the current proceeding, Prevett submitted a defense letter to the JCC in December 2025, but committee investigators concluded that his explanations lacked candor and contained factual inaccuracies.

Prevett continues to hear cases at the state circuit courts in Derry and Merrimack while the ethics proceedings advance, according to a state Judicial Branch spokesperson. A public hearing date has not yet been scheduled.