In North Carolina, the campaign van belonging to Shannon Long became an unexpected liability.
As he campaigned for sheriff in Alamance County, he found that the vehicle’s branding made it difficult to engage with voters in the area’s growing Latino community.
The trust between law enforcement and residents had fractured so deeply, Long explained, that many people were afraid to even speak with a candidate for office. Earlier this month, Long—a pastor, business owner, and former deputy—defeated the longtime incumbent, Republican Sheriff Terry Johnson, in a race where immigration enforcement became a defining issue.
Johnson is one of several sheriffs across the country who lost their seats to challengers critical of their cooperation with the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement efforts. This trend, though not universal, suggests local law enforcement agencies involved in federal deportation initiatives may face substantial political difficulty.
According to an analysis by the Associated Press of roughly 250 elections held this month, pacts involving U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) played a measurable role in the defeat of candidates in states including Indiana, Maryland, North Carolina, and Wisconsin.
The stakes of these local elections extend well beyond individual sheriff departments. The federal government currently holds more than 2,700 agreements with state and local agencies, up from 135 when President Trump began his second term.
These pacts, known as 287(g) agreements, have deputized over 29,000 local officers. Government data obtained by the Deportation Data Project and analyzed by the advocacy group fwd.us shows these agreements resulted in more than 6,600 arrests in July, accounting for roughly 15% of all ICE arrests.
Shannon Long said that members of the Latino community have been living in fear and feel they do not have a voice. He added that they have been suppressed, oppressed and are often depressed, leading them to feel they live in a community where they do not belong.
For Alamance County, a Republican stronghold that has seen its Latino population grow from 750 in the 1990 census to nearly 25,000 by 2020, the sheriff’s office became a focal point of community tension. Johnson, first elected in 2002, had long faced criticism regarding his office’s policing of minority residents.
While Johnson consistently denied allegations of racial profiling—including those raised in a Justice Department lawsuit that resulted in a settlement over a decade ago—critics argued that his participation in the 287(g) program fostered an environment of fear. School board member Seneca Rogers said that the county had earned the nickname “No Chance Alamance” due to a perceived lack of representation and justice for Black and Latino residents.
Johnson initially said in a phone call that immigration policy could have contributed to his loss. State Sen. Amy Galey, a Republican, defended Johnson’s record on mental health services and training, though she acknowledged that aggressive immigration tactics elsewhere might have contributed to broader public unease regarding law enforcement.
Shifting Sentiment in Local Races
The political risk for incumbents is not limited to North Carolina. In Frederick County, Maryland, the sheriff’s office was a longtime participant in the 287(g) program. Since 2008, the county detained and turned over 1,884 people to ICE, Republican Sheriff Chuck Jenkins said.
| Metric | Data Context |
|---|---|
| ICE Pacts (Current) | Over 2,700 agreements nationwide |
| ICE Pacts (Start of 2nd Term) | 135 agreements |
| July ICE Arrests via Pacts | Over 6,600 (approx. 15% of total) |
| Local Officers Deputized | More than 29,000 |
For opponents, they represent a fundamental erosion of trust between immigrant communities and the local police, often leading residents to fear calling 911 or engaging with public services.
Long has pledged to curtail cooperation with ICE, citing a need to rebuild relationships with the Latino community.
Long, a resident of Mebane, achieved a historic milestone in the recent general election by becoming the county’s first Black sheriff. Despite his background as a minister and former law enforcement officer, he maintained his professional certifications throughout his career, positioning himself to challenge the long-standing status quo in local law enforcement leadership.
The issue is expected to return to the ballot box in two years, when sheriffs in states with large concentrations of these agreements, such as Florida and Texas, face their own reelection contests. The survival of federal-local enforcement pacts depends on whether voters continue to prioritize local community trust over the aggressive expansion of federal detention and deportation policies.