New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin plans to bring a sweeping package of artificial intelligence bills to a vote in January, aiming to make the city the first jurisdiction in the country to pass meaningful regulation since a wave of concerning frontier AI incidents surfaced this summer.
The legislation, shepherded by Menin’s office and confirmed by two people familiar with the private deliberations, positions the Council as a direct counterweight to federal inaction and sets up a distinctive power dynamic with Mayor Zohran Mamdani, with whom Menin has clashed on a range of issues including AI oversight.
“We plan on being the first jurisdiction in the country to pass meaningful AI regulation since the revelations about concerning frontier AI incidents came to light this summer,” Menin said in a statement shared by her office.
The most consequential measure in the ten-bill package would make it illegal for any business to deploy, market, or sell AI models in the city that have not been validated by third-party security entities.
That same bill mandates a “kill switch” — a manual override allowing a human operator to shut down an entire system — on every covered model. Violations carry a $25,000 fine per transgression, according to Council officials involved in the legislative process.

The preemption vacuum
The move arrives against a backdrop of total regulatory paralysis in Washington. President Donald Trump, speaking at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in China this week, dismissed safety concerns as a "hoax" and vowed to block any strong controls.
“We oppose any form of robust regulation or anything to control and stifle SI, and we won’t allow that to happen, frankly.”
Trump said, using his preferred term “super intelligence” for the technology.
With the federal government explicitly rejecting guardrails, New York City is stepping into a void also being targeted by Albany. Governor Kathy Hochul signed the RAISE Act earlier this year, establishing a state oversight office and requiring major AI companies to disclose safety protocols and report breaches.
Last week, Hochul launched a new AI center within the State University of New York system to independently monitor large models, and state lawmakers are already pursuing a “RAISE Act 2.0.”
Enforcement across borders
Legal and technical questions loom over how a municipal government can police technology that ignores zip codes. Industry experts have argued that standards for AI can only be truly impactful if enforced nationwide, a view echoed by Council officials who acknowledge the package’s language remains in flux. Menin’s spokesperson noted the bills are still undergoing review and that no exact vote date has been set.
The package also includes a private right of action allowing New Yorkers to sue AI companies for “harm” and a whistleblower provision granting informants a portion of recovered fines. Nine additional bills round out the reforms, though the Council is still soliciting input and appears open to tweaks, the Council officials said.
A patchwork taking shape
If passed, the city law would sit atop a growing thicket of state-level rules. California has pursued its own frontier model legislation, and the original RAISE Act was explicitly designed to link with West Coast efforts to create a de facto national framework. Whether the City Council’s more aggressive mandates — particularly the third-party validation and kill-switch requirements — harmonize or conflict with Albany’s approach remains an open question.
The Council aims to stamp its authority on an issue dominating the American consciousness after a year of systemic tech failures snarled air travel, banking infrastructure, and a network used by the National Security Administration. Menin’s office has not released the final text of the bills.