New York City FC and D.C. United are both mathematically eliminated from the MLS postseason, setting the stage for a late-season clash in Washington this Saturday. Both clubs have struggled significantly in recent weeks, winning only two of their last 16 matches as they head into the final stretch of the season.
The stakes for Saturday’s matchup in Washington are minimal in terms of playoff implications, but the context of how both teams reached this point reveals a season defined by missed opportunities and physical attrition. According to a report from Field Level Media, both New York City FC and D.C. United saw their postseason hopes evaporate following a disastrous run of form in the closing months of the campaign.
Why did both teams fall out of playoff contention?
The collapse of both clubs can be traced to a sharp decline in performance during the final third of the season. D.C. United has been particularly ineffective, recording a 2-9-5 mark in their last 16 games, including a five-match losing streak. New York City FC has fared slightly better in their recent stretch, going 1-0-3 in their last four contests, but their overall recent form remains a 2-6-8 mark over 16 matches.

For New York City FC, the season has been a study in regression. After sitting in fifth place in the Eastern Conference following their first 19 matches, the team’s momentum stalled. The discrepancy between their early-season success and their current standing highlights a season that fell apart once the roster’s health began to decline.
D.C. United’s struggles are more deeply rooted in a lack of offensive depth and a punishing schedule. The team faced a compressed period last month, playing seven games in just 22 days. This workload, combined with critical injuries, has left the roster depleted.
“When we are missing one, two, three starters, it will be tight,” coach Rene Weiler said. “Now we’ve paid the price, with many games in a row and now really tough results.”
How have injuries impacted the rosters?
Injuries have been the primary architect of failure for both sides, though the specific impact varies by club. D.C. United has been gutted by the absence of key attacking players. Louis Munteanu, who contributed six goals and four assists, was sidelined by an ankle injury while with the Romanian national team last month. Furthermore, the team has been without its leading scorer, Tai Baribo, who has 16 goals, due to a hip injury that has kept him out of the last two matches.

New York City FC coach Pascal Jansen identified roster availability as the decisive factor in their disappointing encore following last season’s Eastern Conference final appearance. The drop in healthy players has fundamentally altered the team’s ability to compete at a high level.
The statistical drop in availability is stark:
| Metric | Last Season | Current Season |
|---|---|---|
| Roster Availability Rate | Approximately 92% | 70% – 75% |
Jansen noted that this decline in availability has had a “significant impact” on the roster’s ability to maintain its previous standards.
Who will provide the offense this Saturday?
With the postseason out of reach, both teams will rely on specific individuals to drive their results in Washington. D.C. United will look to Lucas Bartlett, who has four goals, and Keisuke Kurokawa, who has recorded six assists, to compensate for the absence of Munteanu and Baribo.
New York City FC possesses a more intact attacking core, centered around Nicolas Fernandez, who has tallied 16 goals and 10 assists, and Agustin Ojeda, who has five goals and 11 assists. Despite these individual numbers, the team’s collective struggle to find wins has overshadowed their statistical output.
The history between these two sides suggests D.C. United has found ways to win even when the matchup is tight. When the teams met earlier this year on May 3, D.C. United secured a 2-0 victory, fueled by two goals from Munteanu and four saves from goalkeeper Sean Johnson.
The match takes place this Saturday afternoon in Washington.