New York homebuyers had 13.6 percent more listings but closed deals slipped 6.1 percent to 10,042 as pending contracts fell 10.5 percent to 8,949, NYSAR reported Thursday.
New York homebuyers had 13.6 percent more listings to choose from last month than they did a year ago, NYSAR reported Thursday.
The surge lifted active supply to 35,384 homes and pushed months' supply to 4.0, up from 3.5 in October 2025, though still short of the 6.0-to-6.5-month range that indicates a balanced market.
At the same time, closed deals slipped 6.1 percent to 10,042 and pending contracts fell 10.5 percent to 8,949, a clear sign that buyers are hesitating even as options expand. The statewide median price edged up 1.8 percent to $435,000, marking the 38th month of year-over-year gains in the last 39.
“Buyers have more choices than they’ve had in a while, and pricing remains resilient across our footprint,” said Richard Haggerty, CEO of OneKey® MLS.
Mortgage rates are the obvious brake. Freddie Mac’s weekly survey showed the 30-year fixed average climbing to 7.33 percent in October, up from 6.86 percent in September and a full point above the 6.25 percent buyers saw a year earlier.
That jump adds hundreds of dollars to a monthly payment on a median-priced home, shrinking the pool of qualified borrowers just as sellers decide to test the market. New listings statewide rose a modest 3.8 percent to 13,260, suggesting the inventory build is driven as much by homes sitting longer as by a flood of fresh supply.
The metro-area data from OneKey® MLS sharpens the picture. Across the 11 counties it covers — including Bronx, Dutchess, Manhattan (New York County), Nassau, Orange, Putnam, Queens, Rockland, Suffolk, Sullivan, and Westchester — the all-property median price jumped 2.9 percent to $700,000, well above the statewide figure.
Single-family homes led with a 4.7 percent gain to $775,000, while condo prices surged 6.2 percent to $560,000 even as condo inventory leapt 19.3 percent to 2,769 units, pushing that segment’s supply to 5.3 months. Co-ops were the lone bright spot for activity: closed sales rose 5.3 percent to 581 and pending deals ticked up 1.4 percent, with the median price holding at $299,000.
| Metric | Statewide (NYSAR) | Metro Region (OneKey® MLS) |
|---|---|---|
| Median price change (YoY) | +1.8% to $435,000 | +2.9% to $700,000 |
| Closed sales change (YoY) | -6.1% to 10,042 | -5.3% to 4,358 |
| Inventory change (YoY) | +13.6% to 35,384 | +6.6% to 17,462 |
| Months’ supply | 4.0 | 5.3 (condos) |
Sellers in both datasets are still commanding near-full asking prices. OneKey® reported sellers received 99.2 percent of original list price for single-family homes and 98.7 percent overall, indicating that well-priced properties continue to draw multiple offers despite the slower pace.
Nationally, the context is similar: existing-home sales rose 1.5 percent month-over-month in September to a 3.99 million annualized rate but remained 2.2 percent below a year ago, while the U.S. median price climbed 1.3 percent to $417,500 — the 39th straight month of annual gains — with inventory at a 4.8-month supply.
New York State, the fourth most populous in the nation with over 20 million residents, has long concentrated its people and economic weight downstate. New York City alone holds the title of the country’s most populous city, while Long Island ranks as the nation’s most populous island; together with the lower Hudson Valley, these areas account for roughly two-thirds of the state’s population.
This geographic concentration helps explain why the 11-county metro region tracked by OneKey® MLS — spanning the five boroughs, Long Island, and the lower Hudson Valley — posts a median price of $700,000, far above the $435,000 statewide figure.
The divergence between rising prices and falling volume creates a standoff. The next inflection point arrives with the November rate data and the Federal Reserve’s December 17 policy decision. Until then, the market moves in slow motion: more homes, fewer deals, and prices that refuse to break.