Oklahoma Supreme Court referee Meredith Wolfe heard arguments Thursday on whether to disqualify Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready and his chosen hearing examiner from a proceeding that could force insurers to justify the state’s soaring homeowners premiums.
The hearing, held in Oklahoma City, pits Mulready against Attorney General Gentner Drummond and Commissioner-elect Bob Sullivan, who takes office January 11. Attorneys for Drummond and Sullivan argued Mulready has prejudged the central question — whether Oklahoma’s insurance market is competitive — pointing to a January 7 press release in which his department declared the market competitive before any hearing took place.
“Resolving that question, the fairness of the rates, it needs to be made in a process that is transparent and fair,” said Michael Burrage, a former federal judge representing Drummond. “It must be free of bias. It must be free of impropriety or the appearance of it, and that’s what the people of Oklahoma deserve.”
The Wizard of Oz analogy
Former Attorney General Mike Hunter, representing Sullivan, invoked The Wizard of Oz to describe Mulready’s role. “Dorothy says to the wizard, ‘You are a very bad man.’ The wizard answers, ‘Oh no, my dear, I’m a very good man. I’m just a very bad wizard,'” Hunter told the referee. “At least within the confines of the competitiveness hearing, I think Mulready has done badly.”

Mulready’s attorney, Gideon Lincecum, turned the metaphor back on the challengers. “You could essentially sum up the entire argument of both counsel at this point as: we want to control who decides this point,” Lincecum said. “They want to exclude him. They want to put the wizard on a balloon and get him out of Oz.”
Lincecum dismissed the disqualification bid as “Capitol Hill grand political theater” and warned that forcing a sitting commissioner from a lawful duty echoes darker moments in American history. “There were, at one point, riots in Washington to stop the affirmation of the next president,” he said, referencing the January 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol.
What the hearing could change
Oklahoma consistently ranks among the most expensive states for homeowners insurance. Under a 25-year-old provision, the commissioner can deny excessive rates — but only after a hearing determines the market is not competitive. Mulready has repeatedly said the market is competitive and citing extraordinary circumstances language that limits his authority, and arguing statutory constraints prevent him from challenging rate hikes.
Nine months ago, Sullivan, then a candidate, formally petitioned for the competition hearing. Court battles have stalled it since. If Mulready and his designated examiner, retired Administrative Law Judge John D. Miller, are disqualified, Governor Kevin Stitt would appoint a temporary commissioner who would then name a new hearing officer.
The timing is critical. If the case remains unresolved by January 11, Sullivan will assume office with the power to select a new examiner and, if the market is found noncompetitive, to regulate rates directly.
Lincecum highlighted that shift: “After these hearings, let’s presume that the hearings find that that market is not competitive, who is going to be making those decisions later on? It’s going to be Commissioner Sullivan at that point.”
Mulready has served as Oklahoma’s 13th insurance commissioner since 2019 after eight years in the Oklahoma House of Representatives, where he chaired the Insurance Committee and served as House Majority Floor Leader.
Before entering public service in 2010, he spent more than two decades in the insurance industry, including executive roles at the state’s two largest health insurers. He was re-elected without opposition in 2022. In June 2024, he testified before the U.S. Senate Committee on the Budget on how climate change is challenging insurance markets.
Referee Wolfe is expected to issue a recommendation to the Oklahoma Supreme Court in the coming weeks. The court will then decide how the competitiveness hearing proceeds — and whether Oklahoma homeowners get a forum to challenge the premiums they pay.
Related reading