Opinion: Gruening Says Compact Would Surrender Alaska’s Votes

In a column for the Juneau Empire, Win Gruening argues that the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would surrender Alaska’s three electoral votes to a national tally, effectively silencing the state’s voice in presidential elections.

Gruening, a Juneau native who retired in 2012 as senior vice president in charge of business banking for Key Bank and is a 30-plus-year member of the Juneau Downtown Rotary Club, writes that the compact is a back-door effort to circumvent the Constitution without the broad public consent required for a formal amendment.

As of November 2026, 18 states and Washington, D.C., had adopted legislation to join the agreement, representing 222 Electoral College votes — 48 short of the 270 needed for the compact to take effect.

The Electoral College comprises 538 electors, a figure derived from the 435 members of the U.S. House of Representatives, 100 senators from the 50 states, and three electors from the District of Columbia.

Under the current winner-take-all system used by most states, Alaska’s three electors go to the candidate who wins the state’s popular vote. The compact would instead award those votes to the winner of the nationwide popular vote, regardless of how Alaskans cast their ballots.

Opinion: Gruening Says Compact Would Surrender Alaska's Votes

Gruening warns that a national popular vote would render states like Alaska mostly irrelevant. He says that Alaska’s three electoral votes are only seven fewer than Wisconsin and eight fewer than Arizona, states with vastly larger populations.

Without the Electoral College in its current form, Gruening argues that a candidate could win the presidency with less than 40 percent of the popular vote, concentrated in a handful of large states, while lacking geographic representation across the country.

Win Gruening states that the existing Electoral College provides assurance that whoever is elected is supported by a diverse cross-section of the country, not just a few populous states like California or New York.

He also raises administrative questions that the compact does not answer. If the national margin were exceptionally close, there is no established mechanism for recounts, disputed ballots, or reconciling differing state election procedures. Gruening contends that a change of this magnitude deserves the deliberate process of constitutional reform, not an interstate agreement triggered by a simple majority of electoral votes.

The piece closes with Gruening’s assessment that no electoral system is perfect, but replacing state-by-state outcomes with a nationwide tally is not a minor procedural adjustment. He writes that before Alaska surrenders that distinction, advocates of change should make a much stronger case. Until that happens, he sees no reason to change the system the Founding Fathers envisioned that has worked for hundreds of years.