Patriots’ Playoff Odds Drop With Drake Maye Out, But Past Upsets Show Path

Drake Maye is likely done for the season with a broken ankle, leaving the 5–5 Patriots needing a 4–3 finish over their final seven games just to sniff the postseason, NBC Sports Boston reported.

The math is brutal. New England sits 2–4 against teams currently in the playoff structure and 0–1 against clubs just outside it. Their two best wins came against the 2–8 Jets and 1–8 Dolphins by a combined 12 points. The defense has leaked oil against Green Bay and Detroit.

Betting markets price the Patriots around +350 to make the playoffs — and that was before Maye went down. With Tommy DeVito or Jacoby Brissett under center, even the three “winnable” games — at the 1–8 Chargers, at the Jets, and home against the Dolphins in Week 18 — look shaky.

But the NFL has a habit of ignoring the spread. Since 2020, the Patriots have pulled three stunners that nobody saw coming, and they serve as a reminder that “bad” teams still win games in this league.

The Ravens in the rain

Week 10, 2020. Cam Newton had thrown zero touchdowns and five interceptions over the previous four weeks. The 3–5 Patriots hosted the 6–2 Ravens on a soaked Sunday night in an empty Gillette Stadium. Baltimore was a touchdown favorite.

Instead, Newton ran for a 4-yard score and Nick Folk added a chip-shot field goal to make it 23–10 midway through the third quarter. The Ravens didn’t score again until eight seconds remained. New England finished 7–9; Baltimore went 11–5 and won a playoff game.

DRAKE MAYE Latest: NFL Insider says QB and Patriots 'deliberating over whether to have surgery' — NBC Sports Boston

Patriots stun Bills with late touchdown

Week 7, 2023. The Patriots were 1–5, fresh off three of the ugliest losses of the Belichick era — 38–3 at Dallas, 34–0 at home to New Orleans, and the lateral disaster in Las Vegas. Buffalo arrived 4–2 and favored by more than a touchdown.

New England controlled 52 minutes, leading 22–10 early in the fourth, before the Bills erupted for 15 straight points and a 25–22 lead. Then Mac Jones engineered the second and final game-winning drive of his Patriots career, hitting Mike Gesicki near the goal line as time expired.

Zappe throws three touchdowns to beat Steelers

Week 14, 2023. Same 4–13 team. Five straight losses. Thirteen total points in the three games prior. Pittsburgh, 10–7 at the time, was favored by nearly a touchdown on Thursday night.

Bailey Zappe threw three touchdown passes — the only time in his career — and the Patriots led 21–3 midway through the third. Mitchell Trubisky rallied late, but the defense held for a 21–18 win. Two of New England’s four victories that season came against playoff teams (Buffalo and Pittsburgh).

Patriots' Playoff Odds Drop With Drake Maye Out, But Past Upsets Show Path
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

Week 1 win over Bengals proves misleading

Week 1, 2024. Jerod Mayo’s debut. Cincinnati, a trendy Super Bowl pick, came to Foxborough and lost 16–10. The Bengals started slow all year and finished 9–8. The Patriots lost their next six. That one proved empty — but it happened.

This year’s roster, even without Maye, has more talent than the 2020, 2023, or 2024 versions. The AFC hierarchy — Buffalo, Kansas City, Jacksonville, Cincinnati, Denver — is set. The middle class is where New England lives. A 4–3 close is a long shot.

But in a league where the 3–5 beats the 6–2 on a rainy night, where a 1–5 team topples a division champion, where a five-game loser walks into Pittsburgh and wins — the only certainty is that the games still have to be played.