Mary Peltola will be Alaska’s next senator, but the federal and state investigations opened to damage her campaign are not closing with the election.
Peltola, a Democrat, was declared the winner Tuesday over incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan after securing 50.1 percent of first-choice votes and a lead exceeding 12,000 votes. The Associated Press called the race the same night.
Yet the criminal grand jury probe launched by the Justice Department and a parallel Alaska Bureau of Investigation inquiry remain active, according to officials who spoke Wednesday. “The priority of investigating a criminal potential fraud doesn’t stop because of the election, no matter who wins or loses,” Attorney General Todd Blanche told reporters last week.
The investigations center on the candidacy of Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg who shared the incumbent’s name and appeared on the November ballot. Republicans, including President Donald Trump and Gov. Mike Dunleavy, alleged the Peltola campaign recruited him to siphon votes from Sen. Sullivan.
The New York Times reported the allegations days before the election but found no illegal activity; legal experts cited by Anchorage Daily News say such ballot-stacking efforts generally do not violate the law. Peltola’s campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and Dan J. Sullivan himself have all denied any coordination.
The spoiler who wasn’t
The numbers undermine the theory that the second Sullivan altered the outcome. Dan J. Sullivan finished fourth with 1.7 percent of first-choice votes — roughly 5,000 ballots — trailing even Republican Gerald Heikes, who took 2.1 percent. Peltola’s margin over the incumbent was more than double that total. “He ultimately netted fewer than 5,000 votes, less than half the more than 12,000-vote lead Peltola secured over her Republican opponent,” the Washington Post noted.
Despite the muted impact, the Justice Department pursued an extraordinary civil suit weeks before the vote, asking U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason to segregate ballots cast for the Petersburg Sullivan and delay certification if Sen. Sullivan narrowly lost.
Gleason dismissed the case November 1, ruling the department lacked standing and raising voter-privacy concerns. The Justice Department appealed to the Ninth Circuit, but has not sought an expedited schedule. Briefings are not due until January 11 — more than a week after Peltola is expected to be sworn in, according to Anchorage Daily News.
A grand jury confirmed, norms questioned
Michael J. Heyman, the U.S. attorney in Alaska, took the unusual step of confirming the grand jury investigation at a news conference five days before the election. Such probes are typically secret, and Justice Department guidelines advise against investigative steps close to an election that could signal political bias.
The Washington Post reported prosecutors issued dozens of subpoenas and sent target letters and document-preservation warnings to people believed involved in recruiting Dan J. Sullivan, including Marc Elias, a prominent Democratic election lawyer whose firm represented Peltola’s campaign. Elias dismissed the warnings as an effort to target President Trump’s political enemies.
Sen. Sullivan has not conceded. He called the alleged scheme “the biggest election cheating scandal in the history of the state of Alaska” and said he would accept results once every vote is counted, leaving potential legal challenges to his lawyers. His campaign did not respond to questions about the ongoing investigations Wednesday, Anchorage Daily News reported. The Alaska Division of Elections plans to certify results next week.
The state investigation continues in parallel. “The Alaska Bureau of Investigation continues to investigate allegations related to the Alaska US Senate election,” deputy commissioner Austin McDaniel said Wednesday. “To protect the integrity of the ongoing investigation, we are unable to provide additional details at this time.”
The Ninth Circuit’s briefing calendar now stretches past the swearing-in. Whether the Justice Department presses the appeal after Peltola takes her seat, or lets the matter fade, remains the open question.