Portland City Council Unanimously Bans Cruise Ship Scrubber Discharges at City Terminals

Once codified, the rules will prohibit open-loop exhaust gas cleaning systems and the discharge of any scrubber wash water while vessels are at berth.

“But that’s not what happened.”

Scrubbers allow ships to burn heavy fuel oil — a high-sulfur residual product — while meeting international air emission limits by spraying exhaust with water. Open-loop systems discharge that wash water, containing heavy metals and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, directly into the sea. Closed-loop systems recirculate the fluid and store a smaller, more concentrated waste stream for later disposal.

Princess cruise ship docked in portland maine
Photo: cruisefever.net

The vote arrives as Portland’s cruise economics shift.

The amended tariff will give the city authority to request vessel logs and operational records to verify compliance. Ships must also notify the port within 24 hours of any accidental discharge. The ban does not prevent vessels from releasing stored wash water once they leave Casco Bay.

Portland maine cruise port
Photo: splashcruise.com

The Cruise Lines International Association has opposed local scrubber bans, maintaining that the systems are approved by the International Maritime Organization and that open-loop discharge has “minimal impact on water and sediment quality.” CLIA cites studies it commissioned to support that position.

Environmental advocates counter that the technology effectively converts air pollution into water pollution. A 2024 study cited by Friends of Casco Bay found scrubber discharge concentrations as low as 0.0001 percent caused toxic effects on sea urchin fertilization and larval development across multiple species.

Portland joins Seattle, Vancouver, Connecticut, and California — where a 24-nautical-mile low-sulfur fuel rule effectively eliminates scrubber use — in restricting the practice. At least 45 countries had implemented similar restrictions as of 2023, according to the International Council on Clean Transportation.

The city has not announced a timeline for implementation. Federal vessel discharge standards under development could eventually supersede local restrictions.