Prosecutors Say Evidence Insufficient to Prove Bias in Brutal Attack on Somali-American Uber Driver

Prosecutors say they cannot prove bias drove the brutal assault on a Somali-American Uber driver in Hopkins, even after the victim’s brother heard the passenger tell Mohamed Yusuf, “Fuck, I don’t like that name.”

The Hennepin County Attorney’s Office announced the decision Tuesday, charging 25-year-old Samit Apurva Patel with attempted second-degree murder and first-degree carjacking but declining to seek a bias-motivation sentencing enhancement. “There is insufficient evidence to prove to a jury beyond reasonable doubt that a specific bias was the motivation for Mr. Patel’s actions,” the office said in a statement, FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul reported.

Yusuf, 51, of Blaine, remains in critical condition at Hennepin County Medical Center with broken ribs, a broken leg, spinal injuries, collapsed lungs and internal bleeding that required organ removal, according to the criminal complaint. His family says he is in a coma and his prognosis is poor.

Hopkins Uber attack: Prosecutors say not enough evidence to prove bias — FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul

“All we really have was Mr. Yusuf’s brother conveying that the conversation that he heard,” County Attorney Mary Moriarty told reporters Tuesday. “If additional evidence comes in, we’ll take a look at that.”

“It’s very difficult to get into somebody’s head and figure out what the motivations are, which is actually one of the reasons why we don’t have to prove motive in most of our cases. Because sometimes we just can’t.”

— Mary Moriarty, Hennepin County Attorney

The gap between what the community fears and what the law can prove widened after Muslim leaders called Monday for an FBI hate-crime investigation. Minnesota has no standalone hate-crime statute; bias serves only as a sentencing enhancer that must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt alongside the underlying crime. The Star Tribune asked the FBI whether it had opened an investigation; a spokesman declined to comment, the paper reported.

Prosecutors Say Evidence Insufficient to Prove Bias in Brutal Attack on Somali-American Uber Driver
Photo: theminneapolis.org

Patel’s parents called 911 around 1:20 a.m. Sunday, saying their son had come home drunk, confused and belligerent, and was ranting about a strange vehicle parked outside their house, the complaint states. Officers found Yusuf’s Toyota RAV4 running in the street with heavy damage and vegetation stuck to the undercarriage.

Inside the SUV, police discovered Yusuf’s phone still connected to a call with his brother, also an Uber driver. The brother told investigators he heard Patel ask Yusuf his name. When Yusuf answered “Mohamed,” Patel replied with the slur about the name.

The conversation seemed normal until Patel demanded a turn away from Yusuf’s house, the brother said. Seconds later, Yusuf was screaming, “He is choking me with a belt,” and “He kill me.”

Prosecutors discuss charges in brutal Hopkins Uber attack — FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul

GPS data from Uber showed Yusuf picked up Patel at the Moose Bar and Grill in northeast Minneapolis. Patel later told officers he had “freaked out at something that’s not there” and “done a lot of fucked up shit,” according to the complaint. He initially claimed the RAV4 was his, then admitted it was not.

Moriarty acknowledged the climate surrounding the case. “The environment for our Somali neighbors in our state is absolutely frightening. And it is worsened due to the comments made by the president … and many voices in this state,” she said. She added her office had no indication Patel was aware of that rhetoric, but “I don’t know how you can miss it.”

Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty speaks during a news conference in Minneapolis on Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026
Photo: hanfordsentinel.com

Judge Paul Scoggin set bail at $800,000, calling the allegations “quite chilling and surprising” given Patel’s clean record. Defense attorney Michael Holland sought $20,000 bail, citing Patel’s college degree and real-estate job. Patel is due back in court December 16.