In a column for The Providence Crier, a longtime fan argues that Providence College’s Thanksgiving-week tournament history has become a reliable source of misery and that the Friars’ matchup with VCU on Monday will test whether new coach Bryan Hodgson can finally reverse the trend.
The piece frames the 2026 Maui Invitational opener as a referendum on two specific weaknesses that have defined the Friars’ early season: a turnover rate ranked 273rd nationally at 13.8 per game and three-point shooting at 27.5 percent, good for 325th out of 365 Division I teams, even as Providence launches the 22nd-most attempts from deep.
The author writes that VCU, by contrast, shoots 36.7 percent from three (86th nationally) and averages 24.5 attempts, making the Rams dangerous if the Friars fail to run them off the line.
“The team that takes care of the basketball in this one wins the game,” the columnist writes, noting that VCU ranks just 146th in turnovers at 12 per game while Providence sits 273rd.
The Crier highlights a potential counterweight: Providence ranks 11th nationally with 12.2 steals per game, led by Miles Byrd’s nation-leading 4.8 per game, while VCU sits 332nd with 5.3 steals. If the Friars protect the ball, their half-court disruption could flip the script.

Foul discipline looms as a second swing factor. VCU ranks second nationally in free-throw attempts at 35.8 per game and converts at 72.7 percent. The columnist warns that Byrd’s foul trouble against Nebraska altered that game’s flow and that Hodgson must coach the Friars to treat every VCU drive as bait for contact.
Rebounding presents a third battlefield. VCU deploys a sizable frontcourt featuring Djokovic, Alston, and Harper, while Providence counters with Page, Bannarbie, and Aletan. The Crier notes Providence allowed excessive offensive boards against Sacred Heart and points to a potential Friar advantage on the offensive glass: PC ranks 80th nationally in offensive rebounds per game, while VCU sits 198th in defensive rebounding.
Providence Men's Basketball Game Notes Vs VCU at Maui Invitational – Monday at 9 p.m. ET on ESPNUhttps://t.co/yb6HWu9C9U
Personnel uncertainty clouds the outlook. The columnist questions whether captain Devin Vanterpool (shoulder) and versatile forward Ryan Mela (shin splints) will be available for a three-games-in-three-days stretch. Without Vanterpool’s scoring, the piece argues, John Jackson must shed his passive tendencies. The Friars' official game notes list 12 newcomers and only two returners — Byrd and Vanterpool are the captains; Mela and Jackson are the lone holdovers — showing the roster turnover Hodgson inherited.
The historical ledger offers little comfort. The author recounts a string of Thanksgiving failures: 0-2 in San Diego last year (a 21-point loss to Wisconsin and a 90-78 defeat to Florida), 0-3 at the 2024 Battle 4 Atlantis (losses to Oklahoma by two, Davidson by 11, and Indiana by four), 1-2 in the 2020 “Asheville” Maui (blown out by Indiana and Alabama), and 1-2 at the 2019 Wooden Legacy (losses to Long Beach State and College of Charleston).
The Friars are 1-0 all-time against VCU, but that lone meeting was a 103-71 win in Providence on December 8, 1969. Providence is 4-5 all-time in the Maui Invitational across three appearances (1984, 1991, 2020), with the 1984 title the only championship.
Providence College athletics confirms the Friars opened their 100th season on November 2 against Maine at the Amica Mutual Pavilion and entered Monday’s game 158-115 all-time against Atlantic 10 opponents. The program holds a 108-84 (.563) record in-season tournaments overall, with 16 championships and 14 runner-up finishes.
Hodgson, hired March 22, 2026, led USF to a 25-9 record, an American Conference regular-season and tournament title, and an NCAA berth last season, earning conference Coach of the Year honors.
The Crier’s prediction: a 74-72 Providence survival, setting up a potential date with Arizona and former Friar target Caleb Holt later in the bracket.
| Metric | Providence | National Rank | VCU | National Rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Turnovers per game | 13.8 | 273rd | 12.0 | 146th |
| Three-point percentage | 27.5% | 325th | 36.7% | 86th |
| Three-point attempts per game | 32.0 | 22nd most | 24.5 | — |
| Steals per game | 12.2 | 11th | 5.3 | 332nd |
| Free-throw attempts per game | — | — | 35.8 | 2nd |
| Free-throw percentage | — | — | 72.7% | — |
| Offensive rebounds per game | — | 80th | — | — |
| Defensive rebounds per game | — | — | — | 198th |