Reddit Homeowner Paints Tuscan Cabinets Providence Blue, Updates Lighting

A Reddit homeowner transformed a dated Tuscan kitchen by painting the cabinets and changing the lighting, leaving the cabinets, counters, island and appliances untouched, TheCoolist reported.

The kitchen, a textbook late-2000s builder-spec package, featured buttery yellow glazed cabinets, a burgundy accent wall, ornate raised-panel doors, gold-veined green granite, a tropical bamboo ceiling fan, globe pendants, yellow window trim, a cherry-stained pantry tower next to a black Samsung refrigerator and a beadboard island with carved corbels and a bronze foot rail. Every element reinforced the others, making piecemeal updates difficult, TheCoolist reported.

The homeowner, u/trippedcat, painted every perimeter and pantry cabinet in Benjamin Moore Providence Blue, a deep cool slate blue. She painted the burgundy wall and yellow trim in a clean neutral and replaced the bamboo fan and globe pendants with small terracotta dome ceiling lights. The raised-panel doors, ornate hood, cherry island, green granite, honey hardwood floors, bronze pulls, Samsung fridge and layout all remained exactly as they were, TheCoolist reported.

The color shift collapsed the warm-palette conspiracy that dated the room. The granite reads as geological and moody rather than Tuscan earth tones. The bronze hardware reads as modern matte black. The raised panels read as deep traditional, almost English pub. The hood looks custom instead of fussy. Even the hardwood floor shifted from orange and dated to rich and intentional because the cool cabinets no longer pulled warm tones from it. The terracotta domes add a calibrated point of warmth and, by removing the giant fan, make the ceiling read taller, TheCoolist reported.

Reddit commenters focused on structural changes — replacing the island, fixing dishwasher clearance, buying a counter-depth fridge — or swapping doors for flat shaker fronts. The paint-only phase one cost a few gallons of paint and new fixtures and bought years of a modern-feeling kitchen. The planned island replacement and counter-depth fridge are functional upgrades, not aesthetic rescues, TheCoolist reported.

The brown island, which commenters urged her to sand and restain, now reads as a deliberate warm-wood accent against the cool cabinets. The pantry tower, painted the same blue, makes the fridge wall read as one continuous bank of cabinets.

WonderfulDIY reported that the kitchen originally had three competing cabinet colors — yellow oak perimeter, cherry island and a darker brown pantry — which instantly dated the room. Painting the perimeter blue turned the island into the only warm note in a cool room, making the kitchen look custom instead of flipped.

WonderfulDIY also said that the homeowner added a round white pendant over the sink area alongside the terracotta domes, and that the raised panels give the paint dimension to catch light, whereas flat slab doors would have read cheap.

The homeowner plans a rectangular island with 48 inches of clearance and a counter-depth refrigerator in phase two, and intends to strip the yellow trim around the sliding door back to raw wood.