RI House Judiciary Advances Matos to Supreme Court After He Affirms Abortion Rights Support

Rhode Island’s House Judiciary Committee voted unanimously Tuesday to advance Superior Court Associate Justice Luis M. Matos toward a seat on the state Supreme Court, clearing the biggest political obstacle for a nominee whose past views on abortion became a flashpoint in the confirmation process.

The vote sends the nomination to the full House of Representatives for a Dec. 1 floor vote, with the Senate Judiciary Committee scheduled to take up the matter Nov. 30. Gov. Dan McKee nominated Matos in August to fill the vacancy left by Justice Maureen McKenna Goldberg, who retired in March after almost 29 years on the bench.

“Justice Matos has demonstrated an intellectual honesty throughout his judicial career, as evidenced by the support of virtually every Superior Court justice and magistrate, as well as the federal judiciary of Rhode Island,” Chief Justice Paul Suttell told the committee.

That institutional consensus nearly fractured last month when Amanda Nelson, a woman who dated Matos in the early 1990s, wrote to lawmakers alleging he had opposed her decision to have an abortion in 1994.

Nelson wrote that Matos “expressed extreme anti-choice rhetoric and demonstrated a profound lack of personal accountability” when she became pregnant. She said she ultimately had an abortion after Matos declined her offer to raise the child as a single father.

RI House Judiciary Advances Matos to Supreme Court After He Affirms Abortion Rights Support
Photo: bostonglobe.com

Chair McEntee challenges Matos on reproductive rights

Committee Chair Carol Hagan McEntee, a South Kingstown Democrat, confronted Matos directly. “We fought long and hard for the right to choose, for the women’s reproductive rights in this body,” McEntee said.

“With the repeal of Roe v. Wade on the federal level, and the recent codification of these rights in Rhode Island, there are legitimate concerns regarding further attacks on women’s reproductive health and how these rights may be defended or adjudicated within Rhode Island’s court system.”

Matos, 62, acknowledged the shift. “That wasn’t always my perspective,” he told the committee. “I acknowledge that, but that is my perspective today. And that is my personal opinion. And I am not making any statement about what the law is, and what the law is not.”

He said he has considered himself pro-choice for many years. McEntee said those assurances were sufficient. “Now I’m asking here today, and I know you have answered it for me: What are your current views and opinions on a woman’s right to choose?” she asked. Matos replied that he has “for a long time supported a woman’s right to choose.”

A parade of judicial support

Nine active and retired state and federal judges testified in person or submitted letters. U.S. District Court Judge John J. “Jack” McConnell Jr. said, “We all have deep respect for Judge Matos’ judgment, integrity, intellect, judicial temperament and unwavering commitment to the fair and impartial administration of justice, ensuring equal access to justice for all.”

RI House Judiciary Committee holds hearing on Matos' nomination

Suttell highlighted Matos’ role on the committee on racial and ethnic fairness created after the murder of George Floyd, calling him “an invaluable member, displaying a resolute commitment to the principles of equal justice for all persons.” He also credited Matos with helping lower court costs for defendants.

Supreme Court Justice Melissa Long praised his “understanding of the law, a respectful temperament and impartiality.”

From Fox Point to the federal bench

Matos used his opening statement to trace his family’s arc from Portugal to the Fox Point section of Providence, where they arrived when he was five. A bilingual program at what is now Vartan Gregorian Elementary School, he said, put him on a path to Brown University and the University of Connecticut School of Law.

RI House Judiciary Advances Matos to Supreme Court After He Affirms Abortion Rights Support
Photo: rhodeislandcurrent.com

He worked as a federal prosecutor in Delaware, Washington, D.C., and Rhode Island before Gov. Lincoln Chafee elevated him to the Superior Court in 2012.

“I never lost the sensation, the utter sense of pride when I would walk into the courtroom the first time … and I stood in front of the judge and I introduced myself and I said that I was there to represent the United States of America,” Matos told lawmakers.

“Within six years of coming to Rhode Island, his parents were able to buy a two-decker in Cranston – something that Matos said current newcomers can’t do due to the cost of housing,” Matos said.

Declining to preview rulings

When pressed on automated license plate readers, the legislature’s extension of the statute of limitations for clergy abuse, and a pending U.S. Supreme Court case on state regulation of AR-15s and similar guns, Matos declined to engage.

“I’ve always endeavored to not let my opinions, whatever they might be, be the focus of any kind of public discussion because A) I think it’s important to maintain that kind of distinction,” he said. “It’s also important to the extent that matters may come before me, may not come before me, that I haven’t pre-decided anything.”

The clergy-abuse legislation, sponsored by McEntee, has already spawned more than 120 lawsuits against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Providence since taking effect July 1.

Nomination advances to full House Dec. 1

The nomination moves to the full House on Dec. 1. The Senate Judiciary Committee meets Nov. 30. Both chambers must consent within a 60-day window that began Nov. 4. Justice Goldberg, the retiring jurist, sat in the hearing room Tuesday alongside Matos’ family.

“I am overwhelmed and humbled” by the judges’ support, Matos said.