Roll Call: Collins Draft Bills Claim $125M Joint Earmarks Solo, Cut King Share

“When only Collins is listed, it reflects only she chose to fund the project,” said Phoebe Keller, spokesperson for Senator Susan Collins, defending the decision to claim sole credit for millions in earmarks both Maine senators had requested.

Senate Appropriations Chair Susan Collins, Republican of Maine, has reshaped the credit lines on the committee’s fiscal 2027 spending bills, attributing roughly $125 million in jointly requested projects to herself alone and cutting Independent Senator Angus King’s recognized total to about $54 million from $231 million a year earlier, Roll Call reported Thursday.

The move breaks sharply with recent practice: in the fiscal 2026 bills, both senators were listed on 75 of the 77 overlapping projects they requested.

The dispute centers on how “congressionally directed spending” — the revived term for earmarks — is accounted for when the money comes from separate majority and minority party pots. Collins’s office argues the bills simply reflect which funding source was tapped. A Democratic committee aide called the handling a clear departure from the norm that will need to be rectified in conference negotiations.

Roll Call: Collins Draft Bills Claim $125M Joint Earmarks Solo, Cut King Share
Photo: arcamax.com

The numbers behind the split

King’s recognized haul fell by more than three-quarters even though his overall request volume dropped by a smaller margin, about $200 million less than last cycle.

The projects now credited solely to Collins span multiple appropriations bills: five Transportation Department items including $10.7 million for northern freight rail improvements and $9.6 million for Route 26 reconstruction in Oxford; $4 million for University of Maine biology lab equipment and just over $4 million for a helipad at Lincoln Hospital in the Labor-HHS-Education bill; and $4 million each for wastewater upgrades in Limestone and Kennebec in the Interior-Environment bill.

Agriculture, Commerce-Justice-Science and Homeland Security bills show the same pattern — joint requests, single attribution.

Draft bills may violate Senate Rule 44 transparency requirements

The draft bills may run afoul of Senate Rule 44, which requires the committee chair to certify that every congressionally directed spending item has been identified with the name of each senator who requested it, posted on a publicly accessible congressional website in searchable format at least 48 hours before a floor vote on a motion to proceed.

King spokesman Matthew Felling said the omission was likely an oversight and assumed the committee would update the requests per Senate rules once alerted. No floor action on final fiscal 2027 bills is expected this Congress; Democrats plan to wait until they retake majorities next year to negotiate final spending measures before the December 11 funding deadline.

Roll Call: Collins Draft Bills Claim $125M Joint Earmarks Solo, Cut King Share
Photo: newzly.net

What this means for Maine

For a small state where federal investment drives infrastructure, health care and local services, the public credit line matters. Collins made her record of delivering billions for Maine the centerpiece of a reelection campaign she ultimately lost to Democrat Troy Jackson.

Now, as she prepares to leave the chairmanship, the way the final committee reports are written will shape how constituents — and history — assign credit for the projects that made it into the bills.

“We believe this must have been an oversight and assume the committee will update the requests — per Senate rules — once it’s called to their attention,”

Collins, a native of Caribou, Maine, was first elected to the Senate in 1996 after serving as a staff assistant and later staff director for Senator William Cohen, as director of the Small Business Administration’s regional office in Boston under President George H. W. Bush, and as Maine’s commissioner of Professional and Financial Regulation.

She became the longest-serving Republican woman in Senate history in 2021, surpassing Margaret Chase Smith, whose seat she now holds. Collins is Maine’s longest-serving member of Congress and was the only New England Republican in the Senate from the 116th through 119th Congresses.

Matthew Felling, spokesman for Senator Angus King

Both chambers tightened ethics guidelines around earmarks in 2021 when the practice returned after a decade-long ban, aiming for transparency in who asks for what. Whether the committee amends the reports to reflect shared sponsorship or leaves the division along partisan allocation lines remains an open question as congressional leaders prepare for final spending negotiations.