Danny Pentin, owner of the South Lake Union bar Art Marble 21, is defending an internal email that explicitly limits the establishment’s Ladies’ Night promotion to “biological women,” a policy that surfaced publicly this week and ignited a wave of backlash and threats against the business.
The email, sent to staff on September 19, said that “men dressed in women’s clothing are not women, nor are they ladies,” and added that “there has to be a place in Seattle that defers to common sense and biology before ideology and politics and we are that place,” FOX 13 Seattle reported.
Pentin shared the message with the outlet himself after a former employee leaked it, triggering hostile messages and threats directed at the bar.
The incident that prompted the policy
Pentin told FOX 13 the email followed an altercation earlier that month involving a customer he described as a man dressed in women’s clothing. According to Pentin, a bartender denied the customer the Ladies’ Night discount, identifying the patron as a man.
The customer responded by throwing a drink at the bartender, an act Pentin characterized as assault. He said he wrote the email to clarify expectations for employees ahead of future promotions, not for public consumption.
“If there’s a man who comes in here playing the system, then yeah, I stand by that,”
He acknowledged that portions of the email, including the line referencing mustaches and Adam’s apples, could have been worded differently and said the “men dressed in women’s clothing” line was intended more as a joke. Pentin also said he does not consider himself anti-transgender.
“No, I’m not anti people. I mean, I love everybody for where they’re at, right? If people who go through dealing with body dysmorphia and those things, those are real things that people have to deal with,”
Conflicting signals on inclusion
The controversy is complicated by the bar’s own public presentation. Art Marble 21 describes itself as a “transgender safe space” on its Google Maps business listing, a designation Pentin said reflects a general welcome for anyone who treats staff and patrons with kindness. He maintained that the promotion rule is about preventing fraud, not targeting a community, and emphasized that bartenders retain discretion over who receives the discount.
Pentin said he has taken phone calls from critics who wanted to discuss the email directly, calling those conversations more productive than online backlash. The promotion is scheduled to continue on Fridays with no plans to end it.