The Senate voted 51-48 Thursday to reject a war-powers resolution that would have directed President Donald Trump to end military operations against Iran, the first test of Republican unity on the conflict since the party lost nine seats in the November 3 midterms.
Three Republicans — Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky — crossed the aisle to join Democrats. The lone Democrat to oppose the measure was John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, who has now voted against every Iran war-powers resolution brought to the floor. Chris Murphy of Connecticut, recovering from a stroke suffered in late October, missed the vote.
Voter fatigue over war fuels GOP midterm losses
Voter fatigue over the nine-month conflict and the associated spike in energy prices are widely believed to have contributed to the scale of Republican losses. Vice President JD Vance and Trump himself have acknowledged the war’s role in the midterm wipeout.
Yet the tally was virtually unchanged from a late-September vote, except that Thom Tillis of North Carolina — who supported the earlier resolution — switched to a no vote this time.

“This one doesn’t go to the president, so it’s just a statement from Congress. I’ve made that statement,” Tillis told CBS News, adding he is pressing to address the war through funding legislation instead.
Fetterman’s solitary stand
Fetterman’s break with his caucus deepens a rift that has been building for months. In September he was the only Democrat to vote against a comparable resolution, which failed 49-50, and he opposed earlier efforts in July.
He has called the issue “much more important than just voting what your base might demand” and has emerged as one of the most outspoken Democratic supporters of Israel, Iran’s regional adversary.
The divide has fueled speculation about a primary challenge in 2028. Ahmed Moor, a Palestinian American writer and businessman, has already launched a campaign, and Representatives Chris Deluzio and Summer Lee have said they are seriously considering runs.
Constitutional fault lines
The measure was a concurrent resolution under the 1973 War Powers Resolution, which orders troops home without the president’s signature. Administrations of both parties have long argued that the legislative-veto mechanism is unconstitutional, citing the Supreme Court’s 1983 decision in Immigration and Naturalization Service v. Chadha. Democrats contend courts have never ruled on whether that precedent applies specifically to war-powers resolutions.
The White House ignored a similar resolution Congress passed in June, and Trump has said he is “not rushing” into any decision on Iran, telling Axios from Air Force One that developments would be assessed “after the beginning of the year.”

The funding fight looms
With the resolution blocked, Democrats are pivoting to the government-funding deadline on December 12. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand of New York is leading an effort to withhold support for any spending bill that does not curb Trump’s war powers.
Tim Kaine of Virginia plans to force a vote on his own war-powers resolution, while Chris Van Hollen of Maryland has floated using a shutdown threat to compel an end to the conflict.
“We’re gonna fund the defense in a robust way, but if they say, ‘Yeah, that’s not enough, we have to be able to continue a war that’s illegal, and the American public hates,’ that’ll be on them, not on us,” Kaine told Fox News.

War costs reach $47 billion as US maintains naval blockade
The conflict has cost the U.S. military at least $47 billion as of October 16, a figure that excludes billions in damage to U.S. bases in the region struck by Iran at the war’s outset.
The most intense fighting has largely subsided, but the United States continues to enforce a naval blockade of Iran and conducted a strike on November 17 against a missile launch site on Qeshm Island. Brent crude traded near $93 a barrel Thursday, about 46 percent above a year earlier.
Rand Paul, the junior senator from Kentucky since 2011 and chair of the Senate Homeland Security Committee, was the only Republican besides Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski to join Democrats on the war-powers measure.
A physician who practiced ophthalmology in Bowling Green for nearly two decades before his election, Paul has long identified as a constitutional conservative and was a 2016 presidential candidate. He won a third Senate term in 2022 and is in line to become the state’s senior senator when Mitch McConnell retires in 2027.
Democrats take control of the Senate in January, and expected House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries has vowed to move a resolution with the force of law and “take the fight around ending the war to the Oval Office.” “There’s nothing more powerful than putting that bill on the president’s desk. We have the ability to do it,” Jeffries said at a summit hosted by The Atlantic.