In a column for City & State New York, Janos Marton argues that the case for closing Rikers Island remains strong despite recent criticism labeling the effort a mere slogan.
Marton, the chief executive of Dream.Org and former campaign manager for the Close Rikers campaign, writes that opponents have not changed their arguments since 2016, even as the jail population has fallen significantly.
Marton traces the campaign’s origins to a coalition of individuals and families affected by Rikers who sought to shutter the complex, shrink the pretrial population and invest in alternatives to incarceration. Though initially dismissed by Mayor Bill de Blasio as a “quixotic dream,” the movement secured city and state legislation to improve the pretrial system.
Nine years after the de Blasio administration vowed to close Rikers and seven years after the City Council codified that decision, Marton says critics such as Elizabeth Glazer are recycling tired arguments.
Glazer focuses on the endemic culture of violence at Rikers, which Marton notes has not abated under Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s administration, and argues that reforming jails on the island is the solution.
Marton counters that the Close Rikers campaign has long maintained, backed by decades of history and failed commissions, that “Rikers is beyond reform.” He writes that smaller, borough-based jails near courthouses and accessible to families, nonprofits and defense lawyers can mitigate those conditions, alongside a culture change at the Department of Correction.
Marton, born and raised in New York City to immigrant parents, was shaped by early experiences with stop-and-frisk policing and the post-9/11 expansion of surveillance. After college, he organized in South Dakota, Las Vegas and Biloxi, Mississippi, where he worked with Hands On Gulf Coast, the state’s largest secular volunteer group responding to Hurricane Katrina.
He returned to the city for law school, building a career in civil rights litigation, police oversight and public corruption cases before being asked to manage the Close Rikers campaign. That role led him to the ACLU and later Dream.Org, where he has worked on criminal justice reform campaigns in states including Arizona, Kentucky and New Mexico, and helped pass the federal First Step Act.
On the question of population size, Marton notes the current jail population sits at 7,000 — far below the 11,000 held when the campaign began and a figure that dropped to 4,000 during the COVID-19 pandemic, proving targeted numbers are attainable.
He acknowledges costs have risen but attributes the delay to the de Blasio administration’s dithering and the Adams administration’s failure to comply with statutory mandates to transfer land from the Department of Correction to the Department of Citywide Administrative Services. “That doesn’t mean closing Rikers is or was bad policy; it means that the previous administration couldn’t govern,” Marton writes.