Three Photojournalists Sue St. Paul Police Over Pepper Spray, Pepper Balls at ICE Raid

Three Minnesota photojournalists sued the St. Paul Police Department on Tuesday, alleging officers targeted them with pepper spray and pepper balls while they documented the aftermath of an immigration raid last November.

The complaint, filed in federal court, names MPR News photographer Kerem Yücel, Sahan Journal photographer Aaron Nesheim and freelancer Timothy Evans as plaintiffs. They argue the force violated their First, Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights and amounted to assault and battery. St. Paul Police Chief Axel Henry and twelve unnamed officers are listed as defendants.

“Journalists and freedom of the press play an essential role in our democracy, and it is imperative that we protect journalists from harm,” MPR President Duchesne Drew said in a statement Thursday. The department declined to comment on the pending litigation.

Police deployed chemical irritants at journalists after ICE raid

On Nov. 25, 2025, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents attempted to arrest a man in the Payne-Phalen neighborhood. He fled into a house, drawing a crowd of protesters. Yücel, Nesheim and Evans arrived wearing press credentials and carrying professional cameras; Evans also wore a ballistic vest marked “PRESS,” according to the complaint.

Three Photojournalists Sue St. Paul Police Over Pepper Spray, Pepper Balls at ICE Raid
Photo: minnesotareformer.com

After ICE left with detainees, protesters shouted at St. Paul officers to leave. As police departed, the complaint alleges, they unleashed chemical irritants and projectiles at the journalists, who were standing together at least ten feet from the nearest protesters.

Alleged targeting of identifiable press

The filing describes a sequence of attacks on Yücel. An officer identified as John Doe 1 pepper-sprayed a protester, catching Yücel in the crossfire, then pointed the canister directly at him.

A second officer sprayed Yücel in the face from close range without warning. Five minutes later, a third officer sprayed him again. Finally, an officer identified as John Doe 5 “aimed his weapon and fired pepper balls directly at Yücel’s chest, shoulders, and throat.”

Yücel inhaled and swallowed the chemicals and struggled to breathe. Paramedics placed his contaminated jacket in a garbage bag. Regions Hospital staff would not admit him to the main facility because the irritants on his body and clothing posed a risk to staff and other patients, MPR News reported.

Evans suffered severe abdominal bruising after a pepper ball exploded inside his ballistic vest. A police projectile struck Nesheim in the head. All three journalists experienced chemical effects on their eyes and airways, and all three sought mental health treatment afterward.

“At no time did (Yücel) demonstrate any conduct that would have suggested he was a protester, let alone engage in any hostile or threatening conduct towards law enforcement,”

the complaint reads.

The plaintiffs say police never ordered them to disperse. Their attorney, Kevin Riach, wrote that the munitions “were clearly meant as retaliation for plaintiffs’ exercise of their First Amendment rights.”

Ongoing review and what comes next

The St. Paul Police Civilian Internal Affairs Review Commission is still investigating the incident. The lawsuit seeks damages, attorney’s fees and an injunction barring the department from further unconstitutional conduct against the plaintiffs.