Sherwood Files Amended Motion to Dismiss NLR Wastewater’s $12M Sewer Lawsuit

Sherwood filed an amended motion to dismiss North Little Rock Wastewater's $12 million sewer lawsuit Monday in Pulaski County Circuit Court.

“The Court’s inquiry is therefore limited to two questions: whether there is a valid agreement to arbitrate, and whether the dispute falls within its scope,” Sherwood’s attorneys wrote in a 28-page motion filed Monday in Pulaski County Circuit Court.

The City of Sherwood has doubled down on its bid to kill a lawsuit from North Little Rock Wastewater, arguing the utility’s amended complaint still fails to allege a single concrete injury and that a 1990 contract forces the dispute into binding arbitration.

North Little Rock Wastewater is seeking an estimated $12 million for sewer-line replacement and manhole rehabilitation in a satellite district it services but Sherwood owns, claiming chronic overflows from Sherwood’s lines are overwhelming the Five-Mile Creek treatment plant.

Sherwood’s amended motion to dismiss, reported by the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, calls the $12 million demand “a thinly-veiled attempt to distract from (North Little Rock Wastewater’s) own failure to maintain and operate its Five-Mile Plant thereby causing backup into the Sherwood Defendant’s system.”

The city says a recent investigation found its portion of the system in good condition and that the utility cannot identify “a single permit violation it suffered, or a penalty, or a failed plant component, or an impaired treatment metric, or an incurred repair expense.”

North Little Rock Wastewater’s filings paint a sharply different picture of the satellite district’s performance. The utility alleges Sherwood averaged as many as 131.7 sanitary sewer overflows per 100 miles per year from 2020 to 2025, compared with the utility’s own rate of between 1.1 and 2.7 over the same span.

Those overflows, the utility says, discharge untreated wastewater into the ground and waterways, creating environmental liability that Sherwood is contractually obligated to prevent.

Contract allows repairs and reimbursement; Sherwood challenges termination claim

The 1990 agreement at the center of the fight allows North Little Rock Wastewater to enter the district, perform repairs, and seek reimbursement from Sherwood. Sherwood’s motion argues the utility’s complaint never states that it actually undertook those steps. Instead, the utility asserts it is “exercising its right to terminate” the agreement — a stance Sherwood says “borders on frivolous.”

If the court declines to dismiss the case outright, Sherwood argues the contract’s arbitration clause leaves the judge no discretion. Citing a 1927 Arkansas Supreme Court ruling that courts “will never allow purely speculative damages,” the motion insists any recovery must be limited to compensatory damages for actual loss, not “mere fear or exposure to speculative liability or projected costs it has not incurred.”

Dueling infrastructure narratives

The two sides are effectively litigating the condition of buried pipes without a shared set of facts. North Little Rock Wastewater says its $12 million estimate covers line replacement and manhole rehabilitation and “could change as the company conducts discovery and inspects the infrastructure.” Sherwood counters that the utility’s allegations “identify no specific line, segment, specification, or date of noncompliance.”

A footnote in Sherwood’s filing goes further, calling the utility’s claim to any legal rights to Sherwood property “legally and factually baseless.” The city also argues that the utility’s fear of future enforcement actions under environmental laws depends on a chain of speculative events: an enforcement event, a finding of noncompliance, attribution of that noncompliance to satellite district flows, and an actual penalty.

Court must rule on arbitration validity and damages

The motion is now before Pulaski County Circuit Court. The judge must first decide whether the arbitration agreement is valid and covers this dispute; if so, the case leaves the courtroom for a private arbitrator.

If not, the court will rule on whether North Little Rock Wastewater has pleaded enough concrete damages to survive a motion to dismiss. Discovery, including the infrastructure inspections the utility says it needs, is on hold until those threshold questions are resolved.