On November 18, 2026, the College Football Playoff selection committee released its latest rankings, keeping Alabama at No. 3 despite all six SEC teams the Crimson Tide has beaten losing over the weekend. CBS Sports reported that the logic applied to drop Indiana five spots a week earlier did not affect Alabama in the same scenario.
The College Football Playoff selection committee revealed its third rankings of the season, and the math keeps raising eyebrows across the country. Alabama held firm at No. 3 even though every single Southeastern Conference opponent the Crimson Tide defeated during the regular season dropped their games over the weekend.
That retention stands in stark contrast to the treatment Indiana received just a week prior, when the Hoosiers plummeted five spots after a similar weekend of opponent attrition.
Metrics Favor Texas Over Alabama
Quibbling over the top 25 spots is inevitable when rankings roll out weekly, and the debate between Alabama and Texas highlights a distinct divide between resume metrics and committee preference. According to CBS Sports, the Longhorns hold more top-25 wins with a 3-2 advantage over the Crimson Tide, alongside higher marks in strength of schedule, strength of record, and game control.

Alabama’s resume features wins over No. 16 Kentucky and South Carolina, which sits at No. 21. Texas counters with victories over No. 9 Tennessee—the same Volunteers team that defeated Alabama—alongside No. 14 Ohio State and No. 25 Ole Miss, while also knocking LSU out of the rankings entirely.
CFP chair Hunter Yurachek addressed the committee’s rationale during a Tuesday media session, pointing to the consistency of Alabama’s squad on the field.
BREAKING: ALABAMA REMAINS NO. 3 IN THE CFP RANKINGS 🏈 College Football Playoff Top 25 1. Georgia 2. Utah 3. Alabama 4. UCLA 5. Texas 6. Notre Dame 7. Miami 8. Indiana 9. Tennessee 10. BYU 11. Wake Forest 12. Texas Tech 13. Oregon 14. Ohio State 15. Iowa 16. Kentucky 17. Boise… pic.twitter.com/Bu08Lm017K
“I think when we look at Alabama and their consistency throughout the conference schedule,” Hunter Yurachek, CFP selection committee chair, told CBS Sports. “I mentioned their point spread in their conference games is close to 23 points a game; Texas is not in that same ballpark. I think just the consistency from one game to the next, even the consistency within a game.”
Indiana and Ohio State Movements Spark Debate
While Alabama stays on top, other programs face more uncertain conditions. Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti previously called out his team’s positioning using clown emojis, and the Hoosiers moved up just one spot to No. 9 following a 27-13 win over No. 18 USC. Their lone loss remains a defeat against a full-strength Ohio State team.
Meanwhile, the Buckeyes climbed six spots to No. 14 after securing a nine-point win over unranked Northwestern. That trajectory surprised observers given that the Julian Sayin-less team lost to USC and Oregon.

Further down the poll, South Carolina clung to the No. 21 spot following a 34-6 loss to Arkansas. The inclusion of four-loss SEC teams like the Gamecocks, Oklahoma, Florida, and Ole Miss continues to fuel criticism that the committee protects conference weight, while keeping Group of Six contenders like Liberty and Memphis out of the top 25 entirely.