Simon Harris Warns EU Chief’s Digital Tax Proposal Is Unfair, Irish Independent

European Council president António Costa revived his proposal for an EU-wide tax on digital services as part of efforts to reach an agreement on the bloc’s budget.

Simon Harris warns that the EU chief’s digital tax proposal is unfair and would deter investors, according to the Irish Independent.

Taoiseach Micheál Martin said Ireland does not support António Costa’s proposal for an EU-wide tax on digital services, stating that “Global taxation has to be done globally,” and that global taxation was meant to be dealt with by the BEPS (Base Erosion and Profit Shifting) process, according to The Irish Times.

According to The Irish Times, the EU’s budget for 2028 to 2034, as detailed in Costa’s Saturday proposals, would decrease from the European Commission’s initial €1.76 trillion suggestion to €1.58 trillion; this represents a reduction of 10 per cent, or €180.5 billion in constant 2025 prices.

Costa stated, “I’m confident that this proposal is a good basis for moving towards an agreement,” according to The Irish Times.

Documents shared by the council indicate that the draft from Costa specifies the tax applies to firms having an EU digital activity turnover of no less than €50 million and a worldwide turnover exceeding €750 million; these companies would be subject to “an annual contribution corresponding to 3% of the annual net turnover from online advertising, digital intermediation services and user-generated data.”

France’s presidency said that the latest negotiating proposal for the European Union’s next long-term budget is “deeply disappointing” because it “falls well short of what is needed, particularly on the Common Agricultural Policy, notably to guarantee income support for farmers,” according to RTÉ.

The Irish Farmers Association said the proposal was bad for Irish and EU farmers, with its president Francie Gorman stating that “Whatever way it’s dressed up, the CAP allocation to Ireland remains well short of the allocation to CAP under the 2021 to 2027 EU budget,” according to The Irish Times.

António Costa, president of the European Council. Photograph: Bloomberg
Photo: The Irish Times

Costa said his proposal would preserve policies that “bring Europe close to our regions, cities and citizens and support our farmers,” and that the new combined fund for the CAP and the Cohesion Policy would remain the largest fund in the budget, according to Agriland.

Budget Priorities and Cuts

Costa said “The budget will enable the EU to respond to current and future challenges and to fulfil its political priorities.”

A prior EU-wide digital services tax proposal faced opposition from several member states and stalled in 2019; this was subsequently replaced by a global tax accord negotiated by the OECD, according to The Irish Times.

“If this proposal is adopted it will hurt millions facing severe hunger, conflict, and climate breakdown,” said Jane-Ann McKenna, its chief executive.

“I believe this proposal can bring us closer to a final agreement,” Mr Costa told a press conference in Brussels.