South China Sea Code of Conduct Stalls in Manila Amid Disputes Over Rules and Geography

Negotiations for a “South China Sea code of conduct” stalled in Manila after Southeast Asian nations and Beijing failed to resolve key disputes over binding rules and geographic boundaries.

  • Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro stated that roughly 80% of the text had been negotiated by mid-November 2026.
  • Chinese Premier Li Qiang pledged during Monday discussions with regional officials to work toward an early finalization of the code.
  • Singapore will take over the rotating ASEAN chairmanship to continue the stalled negotiations in 2027.

Summit Deadlock in Manila

The Philippines had intended to secure a finalized code of conduct during its 2026 ASEAN presidency, but officials abandoned that goal at the mid-November summit. Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro noted that negotiators had provisionally agreed on about 80% of the draft text, dw.com reported.

ASEAN-China Talks on South China Sea Code of Conduct at 29th ASEAN-China Summit — Hindustan Times

Despite that progress, core disagreements remained deadlocked. Territorial overlaps in vital shipping lanes, rich fishing grounds, and potential oil and gas reserves continue to stymie the diplomatic push, dw.com reported.

"The basic problem with establishing such a code of conduct is that China is supremely powerful and has no real interest in a legally binding agreement," said Andreas Ufen, a Southeast Asia expert at the German Institute of Global and Area Studies.

Negotiations will be continued in 2027 under Singapore’s chairmanship.

Competing Claims and Scope

Disputes persist over whether the final agreement should carry legal weight under international law or remain a voluntary political declaration.

ASEAN, China hindi natapos ang South China Sea code of conduct — NewsWatch Plus PH

Geographic scope remains another major hurdle. Hanoi reportedly wants to include the Paracel Islands within the treaty’s reach, while Beijing firmly rejects that inclusion, dw.com reported.

"One issue would be the geographic scope," ASEAN Secretary-General Kao Kim Hourn said on Monday, November 16, as reported by JournalArta.

ASEAN Chief Says Haze Talks Went Further, Sea Code Still Has Hurdles
Photo: JournalArta

Internal divisions within ASEAN have also slowed the process.

"From the start of the negotiations, the lack of unity within ASEAN has been a problem. In a way, it’s a permanent obstacle," said Felix Heiduk, head of the Asia research division at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs.

Path Forward in 2027

According to the Philippines’ foreign minister, as cited by The Jakarta Post, Chinese Premier Li Qiang promised during a Monday session with Southeast Asian counterparts to secure an early, substantive, and effective conclusion to the South China Sea code of conduct.

"I think what’s important is the quality of the outcome," Kao said.

ASEAN and China: Tensions Rise Over South China Sea Code of Conduct Negotiations — NewsMind Global

Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro, who had previously said negotiations were “80 percent complete”, was quoted by Reuters as saying that she trusted “that Singapore will be able to finish the discussions” next year.

If not, then the incoming chair will take over the leadership," Kao said, according to JournalArta.