State Housing Board Approves Low-Income Apartments That Cost Nearly $1 Million Each

The Oregon Housing Stability Council voted Oct. 2 to spend $30 million more on a subsidized apartment project, bringing the total cost of the Monarca development to $56.2 million.

This decision means the state will pay an average of $985,513 for each of the 57 apartments in the North Portland building. The units are intended for households earning 60% or less of the area median income, yet the price tag per unit is more than double the current median sale price for a single-family home in the same neighborhood.

“It’s extraordinarily expensive…it’s astronomical,” said Ed McNamara, a retired Portland affordable housing developer, who abstained from the vote.

The approval comes despite significant internal pushback and highlights a growing friction between state housing goals and the escalating costs of construction in Oregon. While Governor Tina Kotek has pledged to make housing more available and affordable, the Monarca project—formerly known as Minnesota Place—has become a lightning rod for criticisms regarding budget overruns and administrative failures.

A massive gap in unit costs

To visualize the disparity, the state’s investment in these 57 apartments could have instead funded the purchase of 116 detached single-family homes in North Portland, where the median sale price is $481,000.

Metric Monarca Apartments North Portland Median Home
Total Project Cost $56.2 million N/A
Cost Per Unit $985,513 $481,000
Total Units Funded 57 116 (equivalent)

The project has seen its budget balloon significantly since it first broke ground four years ago. At the project’s inception, it was budgeted at $26 million, which averaged out to approximately $361,000 per unit.

“It’s just way overpriced,” said Javier Mena, the affordable housing manager for the city of Beaverton, who also abstained from the council’s vote.

Wage disputes and construction delays

Construction on the site at 1220 N Jessup St. ground to a halt in 2024 when workers left the project unfinished following a dispute over wages. According to reports from the Oregon Journalism Project, the Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries determined that the developer, Minnesota Place LLC, was required to pay prevailing union wages.

However, court records indicate this requirement was not communicated to the general contractor, Lorentz Bruun Co., until the project was already midway through completion. Because the contractor had bid on the project using nonunion wage rates, the sudden requirement for prevailing wages created a multimillion-dollar funding shortfall.

Rain and wind moved through the mass timber floor plates, and the site became a frequent target for thieves. Daniel Young, a 43-year-old homeowner living across the street, described the situation as “nightmarish.”

To salvage the site, the state agency Oregon Housing and Community Services (OHCS) brought in a new developer, the Latino-led nonprofit Hacienda Community Development Corporation. Hacienda reconfigured the building’s layout, reducing the total number of apartments from 72 to 57 to allow for more two- and three-bedroom units.

The battle over prevailing wages

Many developers have echoed this sentiment, claiming that the Bureau’s interpretation of the law is driving up construction costs and reducing the total amount of housing the state can produce with its budget.

“If this project was coming in right now for funding under the current costs, there’s no way we would fund it,” said Javier Mena.

An OHCS spokesman, Mark Miller, defended the decision to move forward, stating that the agency had to make the best of a bad situation to avoid walking away from the investments already made in the development. Miller also said that the prevailing wage issue was just one of several factors contributing to the project’s complexity.

Governor Kotek’s office has said that the administration intends to work with OHCS in the coming year to examine current project costs and prioritize more efficient use of state dollars for new production.

The litigation involving the developer, the general contractor, and state agencies is expected to settle soon, a condition required for Hacienda to complete the remaining work.

Income-Based Apartments: Everything You Need to Know — Low Income Assistance