Louisville Urban League Joins the Fight to Defend Scholarship for Black Medical Students

Black medical students in Kentucky may soon lose access to a decades-old scholarship if a legal battle over diversity funding reaches a breaking point.

The Louisville Urban League and the Falls City Medical Society filed documents on Nov. 16 to defend a court ruling that protects race-based educational funding.

The legal fight centers on the Lucille Newark Bequest, a fund established through the 1952 will of Lucille Newark to specifically finance the education of Black medical students at the University of Louisville School of Medicine. While a circuit court judge previously ruled the scholarship could continue, the Kentucky Attorney General has appealed that decision, prompting local advocacy groups to step in.

The Louisville Urban League and Falls City Medical Society filed an amicus curiae briefing to provide the court with additional context and arguments in support of the original ruling, The Louisville Cardinal reported. Their involvement follows an appeal from the Kentucky Attorney General, who is challenging the decision to allow the scholarship to remain active.

The core of the legal disagreement involves how a university manages its long-term assets under new state restrictions. The Kentucky Attorney General and the University of Louisville Foundation have argued that because the scholarship is classified as a “permanent endowment,” internal board policies prevent the distribution of funds that include race-based requirements.

To bolster their position, the appellants cited the Supreme Court case Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President & Fellows of Harvard College, which restricted race-conscious admissions processes at universities. However, the Louisville Urban League contends this comparison is fundamentally flawed because the scholarship does not govern who gets into medical school.

“The Newmark scholarship plays no role in Medical School admissions, which rest on independent academic criteria,” the briefing said. “The scholarship provides financial assistance only after a student has been admitted.”

The League argues that the Foundation is attempting to use its own accounting rules to override state law. In their filing, they stated, “When the Foundation accepted the gift, it accepted the terms Ms. Newmark set, not the terms of its own accounting policy. A trustee cannot invoke its own discretionary policy to manufacture a conflict with state law and then claim to be bound by it.”

The tension stems from Kentucky House Bill 4, a 2025 law that removed various diversity, equity, and inclusion programs across the state. The legislation created a specific exception for privately funded scholarships that were established before the bill became law, allowing them to continue until their capital is fully exhausted.

Circuit Court Judge Eric Haner originally applied this exception to the Newark bequest, but the Attorney General’s appeal seeks to overturn that interpretation. This struggle highlights the friction between new state mandates and the administration of legacy private gifts.

The social stakes of the ruling are tied to the professional representation of Black physicians in the region. The Falls City Medical Society, a local chapter of the National Medical Association, operates with a mission to “advance the art and science of medicine for people of African descent.”

Sadiqa Reynolds, a former Board of Trustees member for the University of Louisville, has been a vocal critic of the shifting regulatory environment. She previously linked her removal from the university’s board to her public opposition to the removal of DEI programs via House Bill 4, according to The Louisville Cardinal.

The outcome of this appeal will determine whether the University of Louisville Foundation must honor the specific intent of a donor from 1952 or adhere to modern internal policies and broader interpretations of recent Supreme Court precedents.