Susan Smith Denied Parole Again 32 Years After Killing Sons

Susan Smith, 55, was rejected by South Carolina’s parole board on Thursday in a unanimous vote, marking her second denial since becoming eligible after three decades behind bars.

Smith appeared via video from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, seeking freedom 32 years after she strapped her sons — 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex — into their car seats and let her Mazda roll into John D. Long Lake in Union County, CNN reported. The board’s seven members voted unanimously to keep her incarcerated, the same outcome as her first hearing in 2024.

A father’s calculus: 32 years versus a lifetime

David Smith, the boys’ father, has attended every hearing. He told the board on Thursday that the passage of time has not dulled the crime. “It wasn’t an accident. It wasn’t a bad state. She did it deliberately,” he said, according to People.com. “So even though its been 32 years that doesn’t take away from what she did to Michael and Alex.”

He described the math of his grief to the board in 2024: “That’s only 15 years per child, her own children. On Thursday, he added, “I’m here asking you all to look in your heart and see a father’s pain, his still-broken heart.”

Susan Smith Denied Parole Again 32 Years After Killing Sons
Photo: BollywoodShaadis

David Smith, who has remarried and has two adult children with his wife Tiffany, spoke before the hearing about the dread that precedes each review. “It might not happen maybe for the next five times or it might not ever happen, but every time I’m going to be worried that this is going to be the time that they may give her parole,” Smith said.

The case that gripped a nation

For nine days in late 1994, Susan Smith stood before television cameras, tearfully pleading for the return of her sons. She claimed a Black man had carjacked her at a red light in Union, South Carolina, and driven off with the boys.

The story triggered a massive manhunt and cast suspicion on Black residents in the community, a dynamic The Independent highlighted as relying on “a centuries-old racist trope framing Black men as a danger to white women.”

Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning her two sons — FOX 9 Minneapolis-St. Paul

Investigators were skeptical from the start. Under questioning, Smith confessed. She had driven to the lake herself, released the brake, and watched the car sink with Michael and Alex inside. An investigative reconstruction later showed it took six minutes for the vehicle to submerge; the children’s bodies were found hanging upside down in their seats, one small hand pressed against a window.

Prosecutors argued at trial that Smith killed the boys because her lover, the wealthy son of her employer, did not want to raise another man’s children. The defense countered that she suffered from severe postpartum depression and a mental breakdown. The jury spared her the death penalty, sentencing her to life with parole eligibility after 30 years under the law at the time.

A record behind bars

Smith’s disciplinary file complicates any narrative of uncomplicated rehabilitation. People.com reported she has been cited for drug possession and for having sexual encounters with two prison workers in the early 2000s.

Months before her 2024 hearing, the South Carolina Department of Corrections charged her with “communicating with a victim and/or witness” through phone calls with a documentary filmmaker, a violation of state rules prohibiting inmates from speaking with journalists by phone.

File image of Susan Smith
Photo: BBC

She has held prison jobs — safety security clerk, senior teacher assistant, office clerk, landscape laborer — but has earned no education credits.

The hearing room

At Thursday’s proceeding, Smith’s attorney, Tommy Thomas, read a statement from her asserting she had “lost touch with reality” at the time of the murders. “‘My thoughts were not rational…I didn’t, think, I understood that, I allowed this car to go into the lake,'” Thomas read, according to Fox News.

Susan Smith denied parole as lawyer claims she 'lost touch with reality'
Photo: Fox News

She also expressed remorse. “They were innocent children. They did not deserve to die,” she told the board, per Yahoo News Canada, adding she wanted to work to “keep it from happening to other people.”

Solicitor Tommy Pope, who prosecuted the case, dismissed the mitigation. “And I think what we’ve seen is, unfortunately, Susan is more focused on Susan. Her remorse is for her circumstances, not for those boys,” he told Fox News.

Pope vowed to attend every future hearing. “I will be with the father of the boys, David Smith, every two years, as long as it takes to keep her where she is now,” said Pope, the person who prosecuted Smith.

Under South Carolina law, Smith can petition again in two years.